This assumes, incorrectly, that each generation of children are birthed into a new separate pocket-universe, where absolutely nothing prior generations do next--including suddenly dying--can ever affect their own trajectories.
Consider genes Alpha and Beta, where Alpha kills women right after menopause, and the Beta lets them live ably to 120. Do you really think there's no difference between the trajectories of clan Alpha and clan Beta?
Or perhaps a Cronus gene [0] which increases fitness and lifespan but causes paranoid infanticide. Just because a gene-copy was made doesn't mean the gene stops mattering.
In drought years these backups may end up getting the herd through the worst of it.
And it turns out that for elephants, water availability is one of the biggest limitations on reproduction. Provide a population with an artificial water source and it will explode in short order.
First you declared genes had no evolutionary pressure on longevity after children existed... but now you're amending it to grand-children existing?
Well, what about great-grandchildren? How many more times must you be forced to move the goalposts before realizing that the logic behind them is simply wrong?
You can't just ignore stuff like kin-selection, which we've known about for over a hundred years already.
If the offspring requires parenting, the parent, once an offspring, also required parenting and so on.
This is not moving the goalpost, it’s doing the similar things adapted in some ways for the environment every generation.
I assumed you were talking about humans. For salmon, the definition of a successful reproductive cycle is simply reproducing. For humans, it takes longer and requires parenting. But genes don’t get selected away when it’s passed on to the next generation.
> "There is no more evolutionary pressure on lifespan after you have children"
is an inaccurate oversimplification.
that reads like you missed the last 10 years of genomics and the Nobel prizes for Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier, among other proven DNA/RNA manipulations.
your point could turn out true, since edits to genomes AND superpowers resulting is what you said wouldn't work. maybe the second half of the conjunctive clause isn't possible, but we don't know yet.
i guess the future will be interesting!
Being too old is a detriment to both yourself and your community. This is why we die. We stop being ourselves past a certain point. Living to live is such a vapid, pointless goal.
People talking about eternal life disgust me. It's narcissism or infantilism in disguise.
You are factually incorrect. You can, in fact, learn and adapt in your 90s. Sometimes (not always) the brain has degraded and can't do so as well, but that's a problem we should work to fix. And there is some evidence to suggest that cause and effect go in both directions there: if you keep learning and adapting your brain remains more capable of doing so.
People talking about longevity and improving lifespan are primarily not talking about having people go on for centuries looking and feeling like they're 90. They're talking about having people go on for centuries or longer looking and feeling like they're 50 or better. Many of the same things that make us age and die are also what make us have much worse health (physical and mental) in our 90s than in our 40s or 50s. Fixing those things will both help us live longer and help us be healthier for longer.
Longevity has its benefits, but if the powerful people can become effectively immortal, then that does have some risks of dystopian stagnation. Like, imagine USSR if Stalin would never die, or Salazar and Franco still holding power in Portugal and Spain, because democracy only became possible when their health failed; and lack of change at top management of megacorporations and major privately held businesses because their owners and CEOs now can be eternal.
You chose to cut off my quote so it sounds like I said something else, and argue with the strawman you created.
This alone means it's pointless discussing anything with you, as there's no basic intellectual honesty here.
If your claim is that most people at 90 are as intellectually flexible and capable as 20 year old people, that's a rather drastic deviation from basic facts of reality. Another reason it's pointless discussing anything with you.
"We should fix this"... yeah ok, fix it. We're not discussing that, but just mechanically extending days of life. Those two things are not the same thing.
While you're "fixing this" (mental performance at 90) you'll find entropy is rather unforgivable, especially for cells which can't divide so you'll have to essentially completely redo our biology in order to "fix this". Good luck.
I don’t see why we shouldn’t work towards being healthier and younger for longer. The urge to survive is built into us and we can develop the means to achieve it.
Entropy is one of the most relentless forces in the universe. If we could so casually turn it around, this world would be unrecognizable.
I suspect your disgust has prevented you from actually learning what the positions of these people even are. I mean, we've had the story of "aging without dying is bad" since the ancient Greeks and Tithonus, and even for them it was a tragic mistake to forget to ask for the "no more aging please I'm fine at XYZ years" part.
But most of all. You're not special. I'm not special. Life is not special in each instance. What's special is the system, the collective result of the relentless loop of selection, evolution, adaptation.
Trying to stop death is basically to stop the loop that is life. To stop death is to enforce death. I've seen few comprehend this. You see, you're linked to your environment. Cultural, physical, what have you. As you grasp to stay the same (alive) and the environment changes, you'll naturally fight to hold back the environment from changing. Which will destroy the environment for the next generations.
Hence trying to stop death, causes death. It's not poetic or vague notion. But quite literal.
Yeah there is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligible_senescence
> To stop death is to enforce death.
No. To stop absolutely all change is to enforce death. Aging is just one type of change amongst many that a person can experience.
You may be unable to change in any way but aging, but me?
I may mourn for the "meadow" that I saw being build when I was in infant school being turned into another housing estate when I was an adult, but I know that change is part of life.
I moved country in my mid 30s. I've visited 21 nation states, and seen how different lives can be, and tried learning far too many natural languages.
I'm a furry, so if we solve all the questions in biology (which is probably much harder than SENS, but SENS would give me time to wait), I'll see if being an actual anthropomorphic wolf suits me.
I've not found the right person to start a family with yet, but I'd like to, and I hear parenthood also changes people.
> As you grasp to stay the same (alive) and the environment changes, you'll naturally fight to hold back the environment from changing. Which will destroy the environment for the next generations.
Non sequitur.
Even the first part in isolation, "naturally" doesn't really apply any more, even if for whatever reason a biologically[0] 20-year-old mind with a century of experience is as inflexible as a natural century-old mind, rather than as flexible and open to novelty as a natural 20-year-old.
Both sentences together is even worse, making you absolutely as poetic as you say you're not.
[0] in this sense: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomarkers_of_aging
You'll find it curious I did think about turtles when writing the comment you're responding to. Can you spot the part where I thought about turtles? Something about total productive life? You know, sitting idle for months on end and staring at one point is not exactly what you envisage in your dreams of 150 year old humans or are you? If you want to see turtle-men, visit any nursery home, unfortunately. It's not a happy existence.
Anyway what am I doing, explaining basics to someone who just told me they're "a furry". As I noted people who dream of immortality are either narcissists, or infantile, and I'm sorry to be blunt, but describing yourself as "a furry" strikes me as a combo of both.
This is not a personal attack, but our beliefs shape our opinions, and certain extreme beliefs very much so. You can believe whatever you want to believe, beliefs are free (and most of them among humans are quite mediocre and laughable), but don't expect me to be convinced or entertain your notions.
The picture of a turtle at the of page, and that you stopped reading before the caption that says "some"?
That you definitely didn't look at any evidence linked to from it that directly contradicts your first claim?
And you definitely didn't read what is currently the last sentence of the first paragraph? Which reads:
"""Turtles, for example, were once thought to lack senescence, but more extensive observations have found evidence of decreasing fitness with age.[2]"""
Let alone the table further down? The one which says:
"""Maximum life span
Some examples of maximum observed life span of animals thought to be negligibly senescent are:
Rougheye rockfish 205 years[15][16]
Aldabra giant tortoise 255 years
Lobsters 100+ years (presumed)[17]
Hydras Observed to be biologically immortal[18]
Planaria Observed to be biologically immortal[19]
Sea anemones 60–80 years (generally)[20]
Red sea urchin 200 years[21]
Freshwater pearl mussel 210–250 years[22][23]
Ocean quahog clam 507 years[24]
Greenland shark 400 years[25]"""
(And just in case your eyes glazed over again: Aldabra giant tortoise: 255 years, even that list is not making the claim you're arguing against!)
Also note the distinction between negligible senescence and biological immortality.
> As I noted people who dream of immortality are either narcissists, or infantile, and I'm sorry to be blunt, but describing yourself as "a furry" strikes me as a combo of both.
- "3cats-in-a-coat" demonstrating how to throw stones in a glass house :P
Seriously though, this is all pattern matching to my earlier claim that your disgust prevented you from learning about the topic.
Your claim, which was why I chose to link to the negligible senescence page, was 'There's no such thing as "no aging"'; your claim is demonstrably false even if there's only one single example (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_swan_theory etc.), so even mere hydras and planaria, simple as they are, ought to change your mind if you were not simply dismissing what you don't want to be true because you don't like it.
Interesting thought. So if we simply force people to reprocreate later in life, we'll select for genes that allow for that, possibly also bringing longer lifespans in general (to protect the early offspring.)
I wonder if education, and cultural protection of teenagers has already done that to some extent.
In short, the path to immortality is to hold off children longer and longer... Hypothetically.
There is no cheating, since we could not modify our genomes and give ourselves superpowers. We cannot live forever because there was no need. We won’t die before we can successfully reproduce.