What if those charitable dollars helped someone in an absolute destitute situation, who later turned out to be a success?
Let me give you an example. In New York there is a non profit called "East New York Farms." If you aren't aware, East New York is one the roughest places you can come across in Brooklyn. They provide kids with the chance to run an organic garden from both the operational/agricultural side and the business side of things. And on top of that, they sell it in the local neighborhood. I talked to a girl who didn't know what broccoli was before she did this program. Her parents just gave her honeybuns from the corner store for dinner. Now they have Whole Foods quality vegetables in the middle of a destitute area for cheap, and it services the community. https://goodkarmaapp.com/np/enyfarms
Think of the marginal increase a dollar creates there vs going to a kid from a top university.
Examples of genius that didn't thrive because of poverty? The example you gave is about kids learning to sell vegetables. Are their studies about geniuses that didn't achieve their best work because they were poor?
Before we can even identify someone as a genius, they have to have been successful in some way. For them to be successful, they have to have access to at least some basic resources (there are "rags to riches" stories, but I'm not sure it's even possible to argue that those are the norm). So how would you even begin answering your question? How do we identify someone as a genius even before they've actually succeeded at something? Isn't there some massive selection bias there?
Since the only difference between a wealthy person and a person raised in poverty is income/upbringing (poverty doesn't change your genes, does it?), I think it's a safe assumption that we're missing quite a few "geniuses" because of poverty.
The statement he made is unnecessary to his overall point, which is that charity can help people. His claim about the "unbelievable" number of geniuses being squandered has no real basis in fact.
The statement was very necessary. If we operate on the assumption that a person's ability is largely defined by their upbringing (and from what we understand so far in the social sciences, this is a pretty fair assumption to make!), it's essential to point out that poverty prevents people from achieving their full potential, and the number of people it affects is in the billions.
Just because it can't be accurately measured doesn't automatically make the point invalid: if you're trying to argue that the population of (over a billion!) people without ready access to food or clean water doesn't contain the same number of potential geniuses as our population, then you have the burden of proof because every bit of understanding we have about nature vs. nurture indicates that improving a person's upbringing allows them to accomplish more.
In other words, he doesn't have to prove with hard statistics that poverty prevents genius from emerging, because our existing knowledge of human behavior and development clearly demonstrates this without having to answer: "exactly how many geniuses were lost?"
> The reason why we can't find examples of "genius being wasted in poverty" is simple: how can we identify someone as a "genius" until they've actually produced something notable?
Poverty does not prevent the identification of. I've lived in a poor community. Yet I've seen genius in people who can fix vehicles, in people who can track animals to hunt, or in just retelling amazing stories. Those people are geniuses. Just because they don't invent some new-fangled iBullshit, or get on the NYT best seller list, does not diminish their genius. It does not mean that it did not exist. And it does not mean that a cash infusion would have made them any "more" of a genius. Open your eyes. Geniuses are not resources to be exploited by people who want to make a good return on an investment.
If the genius had lived outside poverty, they might be inventing nanotech or getting us into space or performing on Broadway.
The opportunity of "genius" is to make an impact on the world, and that is why genius is wasted in poverty.
-In the North America there are n% recognized as super talented people and have some profound impact on society.
-In Africa there is m% recognized super talented people and have some profound impact on society.
For some reason m <<< n, and on top of that, there are many more people in Africa. So that seems like a huge waste of potential in my opinion.
Now think of how much is lost just by missing one Einstein, or one Feynman... Even one of those would be an unbelievable amount of genius squandered.
You're right, statistically it's possible nobody is missing out, but it's kind of unlikely.
Do you really think they're going to go from being amazingly smart about investing money in companies to being morons about using the capital for charity?
I suspect they'll act like Bill Gates, not like the UN, in how they deploy their capital for charitable purposes. They will invest in things which have huge returns, just not necessarily returns they can directly monetize.
Ending polio, malaria, etc. probably creates bigger returns than even their Instagram investment. It's just that the returns go to to a billion poor people, vs. being concentrated in a company.
As stated in the fine article, this is their management fees. So e.g. when they invest $1.5 billion, they will give about $15 million to charity.
It saddens me that you rally on these friggin' aces instead of people not putting their money to work, nor giving it to charity.
And the longer you wait, the longer those charities you could have been investing on, are not seeing any benefits.
So you have two balance these two: Wait too long and charities of today don't see much benefit. Wait too little and you might be unable to grow your money and do less overall charity in the future. How do you know what's the right point in your career? Ideally, you wanna start donation when you're at the top of your career. And don't wanna risk falling from where you are.
After the recent investments maybe Andreessen Horowitz think they got to that point. They've got more money than ever and it's getting riskier to wait longer. So they considered that balance and judged it was the right time to donate to charity. You might disagree with their timing. But hey, remember they're pretty good at this stuff, so maybe they're right :)
The research (and I don't have a link sorry) showed that if an Alumni made a donation, even $1, within 3 years of leaving, there was an 80% chance of them donating again. If they didn't make a donation within three years, the chance of them donating again in the future was very very small.
ie donators donate now. Everyone just makes excuses.
The fact is, you're always 'rich' enough to donate. Give up that coffee or muffin you were about to buy and donate a couple of bucks a week, or a month, every six months or whatever. If you can't do that, donate some time/your expertise to help out at a charity. If people are serious about donating money to charity, there is zero reason they can't start right now.
Sure, if I pass on donating to MIT today (IMO they have enough money already), I might not get around to it ever. But, given that I am unlikely to have kids, if I die, my money will all be going to some charity or set of charities eventually.
(I do donate now, mainly to groups like MAPS and EFF, but my income and liquid net worth are pretty insignificant compared to my goal.)
If you have committed to donating your estate to charity by putting it into your will, good for you! But if you haven't already committed to this by putting it into your will, then you (at this point in time) reinforce the research - which is people always promise/intend to donate, but they have excuses to delay donating till some point in the distant future which result in them never donating in the end (so in this case, I'll donate my estate when I die).
What information do you have about their decision making process that makes you believe that they will select charities that don't deliver great results?
What about success in venture capital, in your view, would prevent these individuals from successfully selecting/starting/advising philanthropic endeavors?
I have a hunch, for example, that Marc Andreessen isn't going to roll up and pour a bag full of money out into the little jar the Salvation Army Santa runs outside of Macy's.
My point is, why pledge earnings rather than wealth? I think pledging earnings is risky, and the world is better off because Warren Buffet did not do it.
Even if you view this as pure consumption, I respect Ben Horowitz more for a $100mm charity contribution than adding an extra $100mm extension to his house.
Due to how the funds are structured, it is different for a VC to donate carry/management fees vs. someone like Warren Buffet to liquidate equity to donate to charity.
ie Donators donate - no matter what their circumstance. Everyone else just promises to 'in the future' and never do.
So kudos to them for committing to donate and not just waiting to do it sometime in the future.
Two things mitigate this: 1) The likelihood that they can keep doing return >25% a year on their whole portfolio is very very small. It's much easier to earn $25m on $100m than it is to earn $25000m on $100000m. See, e.g. Warren Buffett - still a great investor, just too much money to invest efficiently. 2) There are incredible tax advantages to money given to charity, because the charities are usually tax exempt.
That is, a charity that's allowed to grow the money at 10% a year with no taxes, does better in the long run than someone who can make 12% a year with 20% in taxes.
It is a mistake for the best capital allocators to pledge future earnings. They should pledge their future wealth, not earnings. This way, the harder they work and the more earnings they successfully redeploy, the greater the contribution to charity.