News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Psychology About to Come Undone? by jey on Wednesday April 25, 2012 @04:19PM (#3890848)

  I strongly believe that for hiring purposes, the research 
  skills of profs should be evaluated on criterion that are 
  incidental to research. Mostly math, probability, 
  statistics (yes even for psychology) then methodology 
  skills and also maybe leadership, communication skills 
  and dedication to science (last only because it is 
  difficult to measure).
I like the sentiment, but the problem is that to do good research requires real initiative and creativity. Testing for the skills you listed would filter for people who are skilled, but it doesn't distinguish at all between those who can do new research versus those who are merely good at following instructions from other people.
Re:Is Psychology About to Come Undone? by zmj on Wednesday April 25, 2012 @08:21PM (#3891771)
What's your evidence for that? Don't you think it's possible that initiative and creativity are important for getting your research noticed by jey on Hacker News, but not for actually doing the research?