Anyway, I guess that means my answer is "yes".
>If you think the government’s tool is overcharging, you are welcome to file your own taxes and deal with the possibility of getting audited.
"Pay what we say you owe or we'll nuke your finances with an audit". Yes this is exactly my problem.
You might be misunderstanding in what an audit entails.
There’s no direct “nuking” of finances due to an audit.
In the vast majority of cases an audit is nothing more than “you claimed this on your return, can you please provide the documentation that supports it?”
More specifically, I believe most audits are about claiming child tax credit and them wanting documentation to support the claim.
If your finances get nuked that means you lied on your return, with very few exceptions.
Main exception that comes to mind is claiming expenses that are up for debate.
Also circling back to your earlier comment. Yes the tax code is needlessly complicated, Intuit et al. are the ones who caused that and are actively lobbying against simplifying it because their paid services would become obsolete if the tax code was nice and simple.
>Is the free-filing system designed to maximize your return?
Why does it need to? I mean, why do you need a tax return, if your taxes would be lower if you just got charged the right amount in the first place? And then isn't the role of society to audit their own taxes, and at the same time support candidates that vow to simplify the tax code?
> if you just got charged the right amount in the first place?
right amount is loaded phrase. There is big range and disagreement over what is right amount.
> And then isn't the role of society ... to simplify the tax code?
It is about as intelligent as saying isn't it role of society that ensure we all live peacefully, then we don't need armies, defense budgets and so on.
The solution to this is for the government to publish the source code in the public domain. Then anyone who can do better can fork it and sell it, which will make that market more competitive when it's cheaper to enter because the government has already done 80% of the work, but there will only be a market for this if the government isn't maximizing your return. "Better return than the free system or your money back" would be a great way to get customers, and they'd be viable with fewer customers when they're only paying the incremental cost of doing what the government failed to.
And then the government system would be embarrassed if private forks could frequently beat them, which improves their incentives.
The US Digital Corps has the technical chops to do that well if the politics could work out.
To the Intuit folks reading this because your boss told you to keep an eye on the sentiment on Hacker News…don’t worry you can _totally_ have your own fork and since you’re the best you would have nothing to worry about. Since you care so much about the American tax payer, I look forward to your enthusiastic support of more transparent tax filing.
"The rules" in this case is the tax code, which is thousands of pages and written in lawyer. You can imagine how converting that into computer code is a non-trivial undertaking notwithstanding that it's public information.
Is it that hard? Americans filed about 260M returns last year. 10% of it is 26M. Let's say you get only 10% of those - since you're not the only person on the market - to pay you $100 (if you save a significant amount on taxes, paying $100 for it would make sense, won't it?) - that's $260M, or about as much as the government says their whole system, for all 100% of taxpayers, would cost. If you can do better job than the government on the efficiency (not a very high bar), and you only have to support 1/10 of the volume the government does, I think these numbers look ok for you.
> You can imagine how converting that into computer code is a non-trivial undertaking notwithstanding that it's public information.
It is. But there are multiple businesses who already have been doing it for years, so it looks like a solvable problem.
TurboTax is ~$39. Also, the cost of developing the system doesn't depend on how many people use it, and those are only the development costs, not anything else a business has to pay, like marketing, billing or interest on capital.
Moreover, suppose a business could actually get away with charging $100 and that would be enough to cover their costs. Why would you want this as opposed to releasing the source code, which reduces their costs and allows them to get by charging $25, while driving the market price down to that level by reducing the barrier to entry?
> It is. But there are multiple businesses who already have been doing it for years, so it looks like a solvable problem.
That was when you don't have a taxpayer-subsidized competitor providing an almost-as-good service for free.
BTW, that's the cheapest offer TurboTax now does, where you do all the work. They have full-service offerings now, there it could be 3-4x from that easily. So I don't think their business is much threatened.
> That was when you don't have a taxpayer-subsidized competitor providing an almost-as-good service for free.
They already have the platform and 99% of stuff implemented. The only thing they need to do is year-to-year updates. True, it's some work, but as I just shown, their potential market is in hundreds of millions of dollars. Every year, recurring. I think many VCs would look favorably at such potential - and here we're talking about already established companies with all sunk costs already processed and paid off, needing to spend just on maintenance and recurring updates. I don't think it's as bad as you think it is.
That's the right now pricing, which is basically an attempt at price discrimination or bait and switch -- lots of people have common deductions like that and then they get sucked in with a free offer or $39 only to learn it's going to be more. But those are the kind of things a government system would be likely to handle well, because they actually are common deductions.
Whereas what you'd need from a private system then is that they don't phrase the questions in such a way that it pressures you to be unnecessarily fearful and overpay your taxes, and strike the right balance in the interface between simplicity and complexity so that you actually find every deduction you're entitled to without having to spend many hours looking through forms.
So then the customers are the people who have weird taxes, rather than the ones who have some mildly complex but fairly common deductions they can navigate in the free system. And yet not the people whose taxes are so weird or complicated that they end up going to a private accountant.
That's not necessarily a huge market.
> They already have the platform and 99% of stuff implemented.
By "they" you mean an incumbent. What about anybody new who wants to enter the market once the dynamics are different?
That's a different approach, for sure, but a viable one nevertheless.
> That's not necessarily a huge market.
It's not huge, but our tax system being a byzantine spaghetti mess it is, it's bigger than you think. I have relatively simple taxes, yet I certainly wouldn't want to do it all by myself and I do shell out over $100 each year to do it right now - so I probably would at least consider using such a system. The rest depends on how well it works, of course.
> What about anybody new who wants to enter the market once the dynamics are different?
That's no different from entering any other established market right now. Yes, incumbents have an advantage, this is always so, always have been so and always will remain so. It's hard to deal with incumbents - and yet it's possible, I myself am an evidence for it - despite Google being a giant of an incumbent, I am a paying client of Kagi, who are a startup in the space. I don't know if they will survive long term, but that's nothing new too.
Now consider that the people with a $100 need are going to depend on how good the free system is. If the free system sucks, it's a lot.
But if the free system sucks, lots of people are going to be complaining about it because they don't like paying $100, and then it might improve some. The number of people who need something else goes down from 15% to 8%. Then there are fewer complaints, but the paid system has that many fewer customers.
At some point there are few enough people complaining and the free system stops being responsive to their complaints, but the main thing that depends on is how much the government cares about making their system any good.
If the premise of embarrassing the public system when a private system can do better is successful, the public system could get arbitrarily good over time -- until the private system doesn't have enough revenue to do better.
You push that point further down the line by not forcing the private system to duplicate the public system's work.
> That's no different from entering any other established market right now. Yes, incumbents have an advantage, this is always so, always have been so and always will remain so.
It's not the incumbent's advantage which is the issue because that isn't the change. What you'd be doing is closing the door to new entrants regardless of whether the incumbent continues to exist.
Even if the market provided enough revenue for Intuit to continue if well-managed, if they were to become mismanaged or otherwise go out of business, or just do a crappy job while not actually ceasing to exist, no one could replace them because no one else could cover the initial entry costs while competing with the free system.
But most of the time our government does sketchy things away from the attention and affliction of the selectorate.
If millions of influential people were using a system, the IRS would have an extremely strong incentive to avoid negative PR through chicanery.
And we already have an incentive problem in the current setup, anyway.
It seems illogical for the government to not have a free, easy way for the taxpayer to remit their taxes to the government (or submit the paperwork that should generate a return from that government). But at the same time I think it's fine to be skeptical that you should trust the government to be honest in showing you what amount of taxes you actually owe given how complicated the tax code is, and because there exists, ahem, a bit of an incentive problem there.
Is the free-filing system designed to maximize your return? Is it designed for ease of use? Generally I agree that TurboTax is a leech, but just because they're leeches doesn't mean there isn't an incentive problem that should be addressed.
>Then, truly public-minded services can use the receipt to help people understand if their filings were correct.
Do you mean a private company does this? Or something else?