Most projects involve both boilerplate and cleverness. Mine certainly do.
The cleverness I do while not tired. When I'm tired, and less productive, I do the boilerplate.
Suppose I work 60 hours, with 40 of them occurring before I'm tired. Then I get 40 hours of cleverness and 20 hours of boilerplate (while non-tired, you could probably do the 20 hours of boilerplate in 15 hours).
If you work 40 hours, you are probably doing 25 hours of cleverness and 15 hours of boilerplate (while your 15 hours are equivalent to my 20 hours). That means I'm getting 60% more hours of cleverness than you are.
Now, I could buy a four day work week causing an overall drop in the amount of work done, but comparing them based on the same productivity is meaningless.
We had similar backgrounds and he was intelligent and capable, but nobody is thinking strait after an 11+ hour day. And once you start falling behind there is this tendency to either work on meaningless crap to feel productive or add just one more hack for an edge case to close out some, bug you don't really understand.
Nobody's ever complained about the amount of work I get done. The problem I have with this article is that it assumes the more hours you work the more you get done, when it's just not that simple.
Obviously this is personal experience. What I'm trying to say is that everybody's different --- the Treehouse guys are working a 4 day week with $3m a year in revenues. You can't just say 'well, if they worked a 5 day week that'd be an extra 25% more work for them' any more than you can say 'an extra 25% more work will lead to an extra 25% more in revenues for them'.
This, in my opinion, is the flaw in the argument. I don't think it's true for writing code, unless what you're writing is boilerplate which requires no mental effort.
> Some of the best engineers in the world work insane hours at Google, Apple and facebook and put out great products.
Google doesn't have fixed working hours: http://www.quora.com/Does-Google-have-fixed-working-hours
From what I've heard, you're expected to get things done but no one cares how you do it. Some people work crazy hours; that's fine for them. Some people probably work 10-4 and then a little bit in the evening. Matt Welsh seems to work 9-5: http://matt-welsh.blogspot.co.uk/2010/12/day-in-life-of-goog...