As far as I can tell this is logically incorrect CentOS/Alma are upstream not downstream and red hat's vision of downstream OSes is they don't exist because that takes a nickel out of IBM's pocket.
> red hat's vision of downstream OSes is they don't exist because that takes a nickel out of IBM's pocket
I think CentOS Stream actually contradicts this because (I would imagine) it's a lot of work to maintain and greatly benefits the community -- and Red Hat still makes it freely available for other distributions to base off of.
[0] https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/furthering-evolution-centos-s...
EDIT: clarified RH's vision for CentOS Stream and added my thoughts on CentOS Stream
Formerly we were just 100% downstream RHEL with none of this nuance, as you mentioned.
What is in-line with users' vision?
- Free developer licenses[0] (great if you're a home-labber, IIRC you can get up to 16, I think?)
- Red Hat UBI images[1]
I feel like most users of AlmaLinux won't see a huge difference between just using AlmaLinux's release cycle vs RHEL -- especially since AlmaLinux will be ABI compatible with RHEL. I.E. apps that work for RHEL should work for AlmaLinux.
So, back to your original question, I don't know what end-users want more of other than as was said by mrweasel in a different comment: "that's not what some people want, they specifically want RHEL, but for free".
[0] https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2021/02/10/how-to-activat...
I believe that AlmaLinux's approach is in-line with Red Hat's vision for downstream OS-es. Rocky's is not.
I think a potential benefit to aligning with Red Hat's approach is that both AlmaLinux and Red Hat will be contributing fixes, improvements, etc. to CentOS Stream -- and any other OS-es that base off of CentOS Stream. And, nothing is preventing AlmaLinux from snapshotting their own stable releases -- which allows the AlmaLinux team to test and release stable releases to their users.
> the Hostility of IBM and Redhat here has lead me to transition 100% of the CentOS Server I managed to Ubuntu
I completely agree with this perspective. This is why Rocky's decisions really baffle me: why use an upstream OS like RHEL if you absolutely do not align with its objectives? I feel like it would have made much more sense for Rocky to make Fedora their upstream instead of implementing workarounds to copy RHEL.
> I will never use RHEL or RHEL based distribution again at this point so I really do not care about the future of Alma or Rocky either
I also do not use any Fedora based distribution (typically just running NixOS or Ubuntu), however, I find that I do care about these shifts because Red Hat has tremendous impact on the trajectory of most Linux distributions. And the downstream OS-es' responses have been interesting to observe to me. :)