News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by 0x6c6f6c on Friday January 05, 2024 @10:12AM (#38879861)
Another suitable option, which has handled the situation of Red Hat source RPM releases[1] quite a bit better imo, is Alma Linux.

https://almalinux.org/

Similar goal, but is working more directly upstream with Red Hat[2] as opposed to the (as I last had read) undisclosed and non-open approach that Rocky Linux has taken.

1: https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/furthering-evolution-centos-s...

2: https://almalinux.org/blog/future-of-almalinux/

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by freedomben on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:19AM (#38880745)
Yeah Alma is a much better option if you care about the behavior and attitudes of the people behind the project.

The Rocky people are antagonistic toward Red Hat and view them as somewhat an enemy (which seems so weird to me as without Red Hat, they couldn't possibly exist). They strictly want to take what Red Hat sells and rebuild and distribute it for free.

The Alma people on the other hand view themselves as partners and contributors to Red Hat's ecosystem. They want to make their product available for free, but they upstream as much as possible and add actual value to the ecosystem.

If you don't care about any of that, it's still better to choose Alma IMHO because their approach (following the letter and spirit of "the law") is a lot more sustainable than Rocky's exploit-the-system approach.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by tux1968 on Friday January 05, 2024 @12:01PM (#38881385)
> They strictly want to take what Red Hat sells and rebuild and distribute it for free.

I think this is an unfair framing. Rather, they want to take all the GPL source code that Red Hat is obligated to make available, and distribute it freely. They believe this is in accordance with both the law and the software license that Red Hat agreed to, when using it as a basis for their business in the first place.

Personally, I don't have a dog in the fight, or a strong opinion on the matter. But we should at least fairly represent each parties position.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by dralley on Friday January 05, 2024 @12:18PM (#38881651)
All of the source code is already available, in CentOS Stream, from which RHEL is built in the first place.

What they want to do, is do an exact rebuild of RHEL without having to go through the effort of putting the distribution together themselves, matching the versions that are used in a particular version of RHEL against what is available via CentOS Stream.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by skybrian on Friday January 05, 2024 @12:31PM (#38881828)
And that's perfectly fine under open source licenses. You are allowed to build and redistribute your own binaries.

That's both spirit and letter. Don't fall for people making up additional terms that aren't in the license.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by dralley on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:59PM (#38883115)
It's perfectly fine but it shouldn't be cast as "freeing the source code, unjustly locked down by Red Hat", because it's not.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by tux1968 on Friday January 05, 2024 @02:33PM (#38883625)
But that is pretty much exactly the contention of Rocky Linux. Well actually, they don't explicitly accuse Red Hat of unjustly locking down the source code, just that there are now some extra hurdles required to legally obtain it.

They do contend, that they are exercising their legal rights as enumerated in the software license that Red Hat agreed to, when it started to use and freely redistribute the work of others.

If you are denying they have this legal right, then I believe it's on you to explain and justify this legal position, rather than just asserting it as fact.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by dralley on Friday January 05, 2024 @03:46PM (#38884694)
What I am saying is that the code is not "locked down" in any meaningful sense, that it is already open source, and therefore that Rocky Linux isn't "freeing" it. I'm not making any statement about their legal rights.

As I commented elsewhere, "RHEL" isn't GPL licensed, the kernel is, and glibc is, and systemd is, etc. Individually.

The sources for all of those packages, individually, are available via CentOS Stream just as they ever were - alongside the sources for packages that aren't GPL licensed, for which there is not actually a legal requirement to distribute sources.

What Red Hat has stopped doing is providing a git repo containing the exact combination of package sources which collectively make up one particular version of RHEL. Instead, all of the sources are still available, but if you want to rebuild the entire distro you need to match up the particular versions with RHEL. And that's exactly what Alma Linux does.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by tux1968 on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:00PM (#38884863)
Okay, so the source is 100% freely available. And with that source, and nothing else, you are able to regenerate RHEL binaries.

Rocky Linux contends they are not doing anything illegal in the methods used to obtain the source code (ie. legally renting an RHEL VM from any number of providers, and downloading the SRPMS).

Maybe Red Hat wishes this was illegal, but I still haven't heard anyone claim that it is.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by dralley on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:01PM (#38884880)
I'm not claiming that either, so what's your point. I'm just saying that the way Rocky presents it is mostly marketing. The cleverness is to save themselves effort, not to do something they weren't being allowed to do previously.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by tux1968 on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:26PM (#38885191)
I'm not sure why you weighed in on the subject then, other than to advance your own personal preference. At least, I mistook it as an objection to Rocky Linux's very existence. As long as what they're doing is legal, then let them be. Each distribution will rise and fall based on the value it provides.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by tremon on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:23PM (#38896149)
The RHEL subscription license comes with a stipulation that the recipient does not distribute the RHEL sources further, under pain of license termination. I'd call that unjustly locked down by Red Hat.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by Nullabillity on Friday January 05, 2024 @02:27PM (#38883533)
But Red Hat is the enemy!

> which seems so weird to me as without Red Hat, they couldn't possibly exist

If Red Hat didn't exist, they wouldn't need to exist. Nobody would need to test their stuff against RH, and nobody would need to run garbage that the upstream vendors only bothered to test against RH.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by chasil on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:14AM (#38880670)
As I understand it, Alma is following the stream release, which is slightly upstream and less stable than RHEL.

https://linux.slashdot.org/story/23/07/29/0214234/almalinux-...

Rocky and SUSE Liberty Linux aim to be bug-for-bug compatible with RHEL, which has become more difficult.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by heywoodlh on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:52AM (#38881233)
> which is slightly upstream and less stable than RHEL

As a user who almost exclusively uses rolling release OS-es, is this actually something people care about? CentOS Stream is downstream of Fedora -- and Fedora is a rock solid base. It's not like CentOS Stream is riddled with bugs, broken features, etc.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by orthoxerox on Friday January 05, 2024 @03:35PM (#38884529)
Yes, this is something people running servers want. A lot of enterprisey software is supported only on LTS releases of operating systems.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by josephcsible on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:01PM (#38884882)
If you wanted a distro that was similar to but not exactly the same as RHEL, then Fedora itself would be a way better choice. And if you care that it's exactly the same as RHEL, then CentOS Stream doesn't cut it.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by dralley on Friday January 05, 2024 @09:36PM (#38887788)
This is absurd. CentOS Stream isn't just "similar", it has ABI compatibility with RHEL, it's waaaaay more stable than Fedora because the most it can be different from RHEL in general terms is the difference between two Y-releases (e.g. 9.Y -> 9.Y+1)
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by bennyvasquez on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:56AM (#38881313)
AlmaLinux matches releases and versions with RHEL. More clarification in this 2-minute video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DNMnajmyLaA
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by iseletsk on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:40AM (#38881048)
Alma is not following stream. It sues stream sources but selects only the right patches - to be fully binary compatible with RHEL
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by chasil on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:44AM (#38881115)
> It sues stream sources

Beware the Freudian slip.

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by bityard on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:25AM (#38880841)
This is the first time I have heard of SUSE Liberty Linux as an alternative to RHEL... when I went searching for information on it, all I could find was the product page and some press releases.

It's hard to read between the lines of the marketing speak but it sounds like it's just a suite of paid support options for existing RHEL/CentOS deployments and not a RHEL derivative that one can just download and use. Unless I am missing something?

Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by freedomben on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:55AM (#38881291)
No it is actually a RHEL derivative, but personally I wouldn't go that direction unless you intend to eventually move to other SUSE stuff. They committed a chunk of budget initially to maintain it, but I'm sure they view it as a stepping stone or bridge SLE.
Re:June 30th, 2024, will bring the End of Life (EOL) of Cent... by dissident_coder on Friday January 05, 2024 @12:01PM (#38881382)
Alma Linux is getting their source packages from Stream but they are using the exact same versions that are in the current Redhat release.