News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Curious Case of MD5 by JeffSnazz on Thursday January 04, 2024 @04:16AM (#38864862)
> And tbh, I don't understand the urge of people to defend broken hash functions. Just use a safe one, even if you think you "don't need it".

The ideal discourse would not imply a binary sense of "safety" at all, much less for a function evaluated outside the context and needs of its usage....

Re:The Curious Case of MD5 by hannob on Thursday January 04, 2024 @07:44AM (#38866311)
The thing is: We have a binary definition of safety for cryptographic hash functions, and it works well.

You can add a non-binary sense of safety to cryptographic hash functions, but it makes stuff a lot more complicated for no good reason. If you use the "preimage-safe-but-not-collission-safe" ones, you need to do a lot more analysis to show safety of your whole construction. You could do that, but it gives you no advantage.