Re:Thou Shalt Not Commit Logical Fallacies [poster]
by jiggy2011 on Tuesday April 24, 2012 @02:06AM
(#3882669)
The only thing more annoying than people who regularly commit logical fallacies are teenagers who argue on the Internet having just read the wikipedia page on logical fallacies.
For example: "the british medical association has said that smoking increases risk of cancer" therefor it is best not to smoke.
At which point you will get "Aha! You just committed appeal to authority and a slippery slope fallacy, you must be wrong!".
I suppose this is partly because in real life arguments we very rarely have sufficient knowledge in any subject to make concrete formal arguments based on direct observations, we are usually discussing the likelyhood of different things being true.
For example: "the british medical association has said that smoking increases risk of cancer" therefor it is best not to smoke.
At which point you will get "Aha! You just committed appeal to authority and a slippery slope fallacy, you must be wrong!".
I suppose this is partly because in real life arguments we very rarely have sufficient knowledge in any subject to make concrete formal arguments based on direct observations, we are usually discussing the likelyhood of different things being true.