> make clown car hardware
I'm not a native English speaker so this appears to me as a bit confrontational and/or an attempt to ridicule me or the points that I am making? I do not work with clowns, cars, or hardware.
> full history
I can see one benefit, and that is the case of sensitive software for special use (eg govt. mil, etc). Here, I agree that in the case of a vuln being discovered it could be a good thing to go back and trace the origin. So, I'm not opposed to keeping history, it's just not relevant to any particular extent for the types of tasks I do in my current $job.
My stance is more like, if I'll never use any of this stuff, why keep it at all? It's not about costs it's just keeping things simple
The problem with “fix it now” is that I didn’t know for sure that our behavior was wrong, I just knew that a consumer of our microservice had begun alerting on errors. I had to find out whether this was a mistake (which maybe I could safely fix) or important and intended (and any change must be negotiated with other consumers). It comes with having an old, complex system with a lot of dependencies and without exhaustive documentation.
Right now I have a full clone of a pretty large monorepo dating back almost nine years, and the .git dir is less than half of the total space. Sparse checkouts and shallow clones can make clown car hardware sort of work, but I do not want to go back to the pre-git days and try to work without full history to conserve 0.008 TB of SSD. We spend more than that on coffee.