News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und... by mc32 on Monday April 23, 2012 @03:05PM (#3880408)
>As I did so, the short asian guard said very intently at me, in a way he was trying to assert his authoritative role, and said gruffly "GOOD MORNING" and glared at me as I walked by - so I continued staring at him.

If that were my job -to guard a bank or whatever, I too would eye everyone with suspicion, as my default behavior. If I were a greeter, on the other hand, I would trust everyone as my default behavior.

Maybe it's just me, but if I were getting paid to guard, I would at least try to do so. I don't mean I would be a dick to everyone, but I would certainly "watch" as many people as walked into my field of vision.

I'm not sure acting relaxed and friendly and being off-guard would serve me in the capacity of being a guard. (Altho' I'm open to being corrected, if this assumption is incorrect).

Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und... by samstave on Monday April 23, 2012 @03:33PM (#3880547)
If being looked at by a well dressed business man sets off your alarms as though you believe you are being cased, to the point where you feel you need to have your weapon hand at the ready - then screw that.

Screw this guard and every single mentality that supports him and people like him.

I am not a fan of the police state - and the last person I have any respect for is an armed civilian who believes himself to be some arm of the law.

Simply put, he is a hired thug for the bank. I give him no greater mind, or respect because he is wearing military like clothing. Here I went back and took this picture of him:

http://i.imgur.com/E0rjw.jpg

edit: and to be clear, if I were casing him - he would never know it. If I had bad intentions for him - clearly I would have used a moment like this where he was texting on his phone and oblivious to those around him to spring Operation Currency Liberation.

Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und... by mc32 on Monday April 23, 2012 @10:41PM (#3882178)
>If being looked at by a well dressed business man sets off your alarms

If I were a guard, I would not make any assumptions about how people are dressed.

>to the point where you feel you need to have your weapon hand at the ready

I hear you. If I were in your shoes, I too would feel like there was an overreaction. I do some street photography on occasion, and I do get weird looks from guards, on occasion. When you do photography a while, you learn to brush it off. Also, If I were the guard, I would remind myself that an unprepared guard is a potentially neutralized (or dead) guard.

We don't live in Japan where you can pretty much assume, that with very rare exceptions, a firearm will not be produced by an assailant.

>and the last person I have any respect for is an armed civilian who believes himself to be some arm of the law

Ok, we agree there.

>Simply put, he is a hired thug for the bank.

That statement tells me a lot. It's a pretty antagonistic interpretation of his aggressive attitude. Maybe he is maybe he isn't. Do we know he has a criminal record of unprovoked violence toward innocent people?

> if I were casing him - he would never know it.

I'm pretty sure you would not let him on. Do we know others would not be more impulsive?

For all I know he is a dick and does explode violently at others unprovoked. Still, I didn't read any evidence to that effect.

Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und... by samstave on Tuesday April 24, 2012 @12:24AM (#3882413)
>It's a pretty antagonistic interpretation of his aggressive attitude

I find it ironic that his overly aggressive attitude makes me antagonistic, but I will concede that i get more emotionally heated about such things because i have contempt for his delusion of authority or power.

>I do some street photography on occasion

A while back, while doing some street photography of a homeless woman feeding some pigeons, in an alley not far from where this guard was, a guard emerged from some building telling me I was not allowed to take pictures.

I challenged her saying 'why?' - she said it was a federal law. I asked her if she was a federal employee or guard. She reiterated it was 'federal law' - I said 'but the building behind you isnt a federal building.'

She tried to press her position. I simply said "I don't care if it is a federal law - I refuse to obey it, further, you're not a federal employee and this is not a federal building" I also said "If I am standing on public property, and I can see it, I am allowed to photograph it. Period."

She realized she wasn't going to get me to stop, and left.

Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und... by mc32 on Tuesday April 24, 2012 @03:55PM (#3886028)
In talking to other photographers what I've learned is that there are two different approaches to take upon confrontation: One, defend oneself about extant rights as if life depended on it. Two, take a more practical approach, explain oneself (even if this should not be necessary) and if their objections remains, back down calmly. Fight another day.

While one would prefer that people not try to exert power where none exists, life will proceed smoother, if approach two is taken (as it regard photography)

Approach one can lead to agressive behavior by [guard|police|public] and has resulted in detention/citation. Approach two can and has resulted in some understanding and acceptance.

Confrontation one: You have no right to inquire about what I'm doing while on a public street. You ignorant $%#^# I'm going to call my lawyer, I'm going to sue you for harassment, etc...

Confrontation two: Are you familiar with street photography? It has a long tradition. You might have seen some of the photography on gallery visit. Have you heard of Winogrand, Cartier-Bresson, Frank? Here, I have some examples --carry some print-outs or load some into your DSLR.

Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und... by rdtsc on Tuesday April 24, 2012 @01:54AM (#3882635)
> i get more emotionally heated about such things because i have contempt for his delusion of authority or power.

sometime people who have no real power will cling to whatever little power they have and assert the hell of out that (put their hands on their gun, stare at people like he did)

find it is interesting to play along and indulge them, i kind of feel sorry for them, it is the little pleasure in life they have, and i just enjoy seeing them gloat with their fake power trip.