Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und...
by rhizome on Monday April 23, 2012 @02:17PM
(#3880181)
Oh please, the sky isn't falling. Rape is not going to go uninvestigated because a police officer can't tell someone to stop filming.
Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und...
by freehunter on Monday April 23, 2012 @02:20PM
(#3880197)
Hopefully what it will mean is officers will have an incentive to actually learn the laws instead of guessing. This creates a disincentive to action without knowledge, and cops aren't going to want to do nothing.
Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und...
by damoncali on Monday April 23, 2012 @03:15PM
(#3880465)
That's not what I mean. Boil this down to it's logical conclusion. If a cop arrests anyone for something that is deemed after the fact unjustifiable, they should similarly be held liable for damages. I mean, why stop at taking pictures? Is it not just as much an inconvenience to be arbitrarily arrested for burglary?
Throw in the culture of the police corps - and you could see a lot more "not my job" type behavior from the police. This sort of law could very well be interpreted as a slap by an ungrateful populace.
I'm just saying there is a balance here. Us vs. them isn't likely to result in improvement. This law seems very knee-jerky to me.
Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und...
by rhizome on Monday April 23, 2012 @03:23PM
(#3880502)
Don't change the subject, it's exactly what you mean. This law doesn't cover "anyone" for "something," it's covers photography, period.
Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und...
by damoncali on Monday April 23, 2012 @03:26PM
(#3880517)
You're missing the bigger point. Look at the message sent. It's bigger than some hippie taking pictures at an occupy berkeley event.
Re:Cops Would Be Liable Arresting Citizens For Recording Und...
by rhizome on Monday April 23, 2012 @03:33PM
(#3880546)
No, I'm not. I simply don't agree that there is a "bigger point" at all, nor that this is a slippery-slope that must be guarded.
These ideas tend to come with unintended consequences.