That they are is just speculation from someone whose taken his experience and projected it onto everybody.
Since he's a person who mucks around with random system settings (like the one in his article) there's no telling what previous damage he's done to cause this problem.
EDIT: I can't get either spotlight or time machine to show any cache polluting behavior at all, at least not in the way that I run them. I used "mdutil -E /" to force a re-index of my disk, and I kicked off an initial time machine backup on a secondary drive I had lying around. I see both backupd and mdworker doing a lot of disk reads using iotop, but top shows my inactive memory not really changing as drastically as I'd expect, like if I were to cat a giant file to /dev/null.
I hope Apple engineers are looking at this thread.
I think you could probably hack something together that does this with DYLD_INSERT_LIBRARIES (OSX's LD_PRELOAD) that would would hook the open system call and fcntl F_NOCACHE on the file descriptor before it hands it back to the application.