Xournalpp uses layers as well, hiding annotations is also possible there.
Just a different solution to the same problem.
Xournalpp, is free and open source. It is actually a fork of an older software called Xournal. If it stops being developed, C++ compilers aren't going anywhere, I'll compile it myself -- beyond that it's just pedantic to discuss what and what won't be possible in decades.
PDF readers on the other hand, especially proprietary ones have a bad habit of, for lack of a better word, enshitifying (cloud, saas, subscription, etc). I've had PDF a editor corrupt my PDF as well (sample size 1, so not indicative of all PDF editors), my fault for not having backups I suppose, but I've avoided them since.
But whatever works for you, I'm not here to dictate what you can or should use. Just providing ideas as the OP originally asked in the root comment.
Anyhow, the only solution that will survive ultimately is plain text. All others rely on abstractions upon abstraction (C++, compilers, libraries, etc). Plaintext is bits and bytes you can decode by hand if you wanted.
Yes, I agree completely. Sorry that I gave a different impression.
> Xournalpp, is free and open source. It is actually a fork of an older software called Xournal. If it stops being developed, C++ compilers aren't going anywhere, I'll compile it myself -- beyond that it's just pedantic to discuss what and what won't be possible in decades.
Few users will compile anything, and eventually incompatibilities arise between the application and the latest platform. My PDF reader functions fine with documents that are decades old - that is part of the PDF specification; it's not pedantic, it's deliberately and successfully engineered.
> PDF readers on the other hand, especially proprietary ones have a bad habit of, for lack of a better word, enshitifying (cloud, saas, subscription, etc). I've had PDF editors corrupt my PDF as well, my fault for not having backups I suppose, but I've avoided them since.
There are many, many PDF readers. I have no problem finding a good one (I agree, stay away from Adobe, which you seem to describe). Yes, I'd be careful with PDF editors - that's not really what PDFs are designed for afaik.
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="7.86" fill="60" capStyle="butt">254.802 713.98302 283.955 713.98302</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="9" fill="60" capStyle="butt">283.955 714.01302 539.992 714.01302</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="0" fill="60" capStyle="butt">539.992 718.51302 539.992 718.51302</stroke>
<text font="Sans" size="8" x="456.87471" y="427.46622" color="#ff0000ff" ts="0" fn="">Here the first capture group is
`([\"'])`, which captures either a
`"` or a `'`. Then the `(.-)` lazy matches
any thing, and finally `%1` matches
the original type of (closing) quote</text>
</layer>
</page>
<page width="612" height="792">
<background type="pdf" pageno="95"/>
<layer>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="9" fill="60" capStyle="butt">120 78 169.674 78</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="7.86" fill="60" capStyle="butt">265.784 77.97 292.676 77.97</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="9" fill="60" capStyle="butt">292.676 78 397.442 78</stroke>Out of curiosity, is that SVG (which is an XML)?
<?xml version="1.0" standalone="no"?>
<xournal creator="xournalpp 1.2.2" fileversion="4">
<title>Xournal++ document - see </title>
<preview>iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhE...............</preview>
<page width="612" height="792">
<background type="pdf" domain="absolute" filename="somebook.pdf" pageno="1"/>
<layer/>
</page>
<page width="612" height="792">
<background type="pdf" pageno="2"/>
<layer/>
</page>
...
<page width="612" height="792">
<background type="pdf" pageno="16"/>
<layer>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="9" fill="60" capStyle="butt">120 457.20601 540 457.20601</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="9" fill="60" capStyle="butt">394.78 515.76399 540.01 515.76399</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="0" fill="60" capStyle="butt">540.01 520.26399 540.01 520.26399</stroke>
<stroke tool="highlighter" color="#00ff007f" width="9" fill="60" capStyle="butt">120 527.76399 156.1 527.76399</stroke>
</layer>
</page>
Here's the top of the file for context.
Just to give people another perspective on these issues [edit: not to deny the parent's perspective, just to add another]:
In PDFs, annotations are effectively (or actually?) on a separate layer from the document. It's not like marking up a paper book; in a PDF the annotations leave the original untouched, and can be easily hidden or removed.
Another advantage of using PDF annotations is that they are retained, readable, and editable for decades. There's no other file to retain. And if Xournalpp stops being developed, what happens to your annotations?