I dont think "re-colouring" or "moving things around to be pretty." really applies to this series. The redesigns seem really effective and are based on a specific criticism of the site (“doesn’t make you feel confident in their claims of what their app does.”).
Why is design the only profession where it's frowned upon to evaluate the end result?
In web design that's often frowned upon because this isn't the "end" of the design. It has a whole interaction component that isn't being addressed by a picture.
Re:YC Facelift: DrChrono
by MaxGabriel on Monday April 23, 2012 @04:08PM
(#3880693)
The letter from the AA designer doesn't support your position at all. The reason he couldn't do a major redesign of the site was because of all the bureaucracy making it impossible. That shouldn't apply to a YC startup.
Re:YC Facelift: DrChrono
by aaronkwhite on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:38PM
(#3879678)
This is the Greatest Response EVER!
Incidentally, there was a designer who did a "redesign" of the American Airlines site a while back and ignited a fire store. The response from one of AA's designers is worth a read: http://www.dustincurtis.com/dear_dustin_curtis.html