News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:17AM (#3879198)
I'm a 25 year-old former Marine who thought he could take a shot at being a programmer when he exited the military. I never had any background in programming other than being interested in UNIX and Linux at a young age, so CS seemed like the logical choice for someone who had a GI bill to burn.

2 years and a lot of classes later, I'm realizing I'm too old to compete at this gig, and I should have started when I was 12, if I wanted to be taken seriously. The only thing I have any skill in is various computer related things, but not one thing in particular. I've developed a very basic knowledge of C++, but that's laughable really. So I'm stuck, unsure of what it is I should really be doing. I could get a dead-end part time job and continue my schooling, but it seems almost futile at this point. I was denied to the University of Florida, yes the school that recently killed-off their CS department in favor of Football funding. It was the top school in the state, but they wouldn't accept my transfer because I'm only now up to the Calculus 1 and Physics level (rightfully so I guess, that was my mistake). Being that I could only take those classes now, it would probably be another year at least, to get to where I could actually transfer to a real university. The only reason I've been able to do this is because of the GI bill that's been granted to me because of my time in the service, but that's running out and I don't have anything to show for it. Other than a General AA, which probably wasn't worth my time - despite planning ahead.

I keep reading stories and anecdotes about how this field is going, and I'm starting to become very unsure if it's something I need to stick with to prevail, or whether it's already too late. I can't find anyone that will tell me the truth - just those that placate with notions of "you can do anything you're just not trying hard enough," despite my 15 hour course-load. From my perspective it seems like CS is an unattainable feat unless you're fresh out of high school at the age of 17 with several dual-enrolled college courses under your belt. The competition is outrageous. Don't you think I want skills that are worth someone's money?

I read about how people with experience with Java, C++, C, C# and so fourth, at least having the ability to put multiple languages on their resume, can't find employment because they haven't done a formal project or haven't been a part of, and accepted, within the OSS community. This frightens me because my skill level is nowhere near where it needs to be to do this, and I highly doubt how much I can persevere with the time that I have left.

I used to open up my IDE with the prospect of learning new things and freshness being able to develop a more solid understanding of what I thought I could do for a living. While I finish out the courses I'm still in, it would appear now, as I reflect, that I'm only doing it to pass the course now, as my delusions of grandeur have faded.

Edit: Wow. Thanks for all your input. This will give me a better objective view to reassess my path. Again, thanks.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by alecco on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:34AM (#3879271)
> 2 years and a lot of classes later, I'm realizing I'm too old to compete at this gig

No, you're not. You have the wrong teachers and wrong texts. In the contrary to what popular posts say, it takes a long time, years, to be a good programmer. You need to be able to be self-critic, completely change the way you do things. Many times.

Pick a decent open source project in something you find interesting. The harder and lower level, the better. Don't be afraid, there's always somewhere you can start. Join their irc channel and email lists. Help with documentation and test cases. They'll be more than happy to mentor you. And switch projects if you are not moving forward for a while.

Also spend a couple of hours a week on StackOverflow, reading and asking questions. Be polite and do your homework before asking. You'd be surprised how many people are happy to help you for free.

IMHO, most universities suck at making you a competent programmer.

Programming is a lot more about stamina and leaving your ego behind than fads and blogs, or universities. Your military background is a good start. Programming/CS is a lot about self-discipline.

Edit: Open a github account and start coding/forking. This might help you find employment more than experience listed on a CV

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:07PM (#3879468)
I like your support because you gave me some very clear goals to work with. I will consider doing all of them.

What I'm struggling with now, since I'm still an lower-division undergrad trying to make my way into a BS program, is do I continue on and persue this - perhaps getting a meaningless part time job in the meantime to supplement my income? Or, do I just go full speed ahead and try and apply for some very entry level IT work. I have no idea what I'm doing in the civilian sector despite my getting out 2 years go - I've only been a full time college student since. Perhaps I'm just rambling because I need answers to these questions, but you seem salty, and wise. Thanks for your help.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by alecco on Monday April 23, 2012 @05:51PM (#3881156)
If your education is paid, I'd finish it. Try to make the best out of it but don't let it consume you.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by jiggy2011 on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:40AM (#3879311)
Well, the competition is outrageous at the top end of programming jobs, also bear in mind that you are reading HN where many of the commentators are above average programmers who dream in code. However just because you might not land a job at Google does not mean you will not be able to create a decent career for yourself.

If you can get any experience working on OSS at all, especially on a reasonably well known project (not all of these are hugely technical, so you don't necessarily have to be some ninja guru). This will already put you ahead of the pack,many programmers use OSS but few actually contribute. You will also have the advantage that you will be able to work on real code and possibly get some mentoring which will help build your confidence.

Also bear in mind that as a former Marine you will have experience in areas that the overwhelming majority of programmers do not. Even if these do not seem directly relevant it can sometimes be surprising where you may be able to find a niche.

For example you might want to also consider looking into the IT/Operations side of computing (running datacenters etc), I would imagine that a military level of organizational skills as well as being able to deal with pressure would be very useful there.

I know plenty of competent programmers who did not start when they were 12.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by ccoggins on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:28PM (#3879604)
Having previous military experience definitely helps get your foot in the door at all the military contractors as well. Often times when developing new features we don't have the benefit of really having a good idea of what the soldier wants. Putting myself in their shoes is tough to do without that experience and having an expert can really allow us to develop features that get used. Also, if you had or have held a security clearance that can carry some weight at the defense contractors as well.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:10PM (#3879490)
Thank you for your input. I'm not sure how to get into the Operation side of things, I might have to inquire with a career counselor about that path, if it's an avenue that I can take.

I'm aware that my time in is worth something, as I did obtain rank that probably looks decent, but I'm slightly edgy as to how it will be received. (I was an infantry Sgt.) Some have some derogatory views of how we are and I'm reticent to mention too much. (Everyone thinks you have PTSD despite studies)

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by jiggy2011 on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:31PM (#3879632)
One way to get into operations (albeit not a pleasant one) is through helpdesk jobs. These are typically repetitive and low paid but if you can get in with the right company and prove aptitude there is often a concrete career path.

It is important to get in with the right company though as many helpdesks are basically outsourced to the lowest bidder and end up being dead end script reading jobs (done those myself, do not recommend).

One company that might be worth looking at would be Rackspace (they host the website for the British Army so I would assume they are not anti-military) they are also a pretty large and growing company.

Another option would be to work with a small web dev shop. Usually they are not looking for uber-coders but for people who can produce consistent work on time. Also Linux knowledge (if you also know your way around Apache) tends to be very useful to these guys as they may be so small that they don't have a full time sysadmin on staff and are constantly being frustrated by the slow response times of their hosting providers support staff.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by enfilade on Monday April 23, 2012 @07:24PM (#3881542)
Former Marine infantry corporal here -- I think lbo's advice to you is outstanding. He/she wrote:

"Anyway, don't defeat yourself and don't underestimate how critical this knowledge will be in 10, 15, 25 years when the world will be a whole new place filled with much much more software."

Maintaining a long term perspective is key. The skills you are seeking will only rise in value in the coming years as computing becomes more and more ubiquitous and distributed. Maintain the mindset you have at the beginning of a 20k hike with crew-serve weapons and full packs.

You are 25, technically oriented/interested, and you're a former grunt NCO. As long as you stay healthy and avoid stepping in front of a bus you will be working for decades to come. You may feel old, but in the big scheme of things you are not.

I understand your problem is short term money. Have you considered working for a year with DynCorp or Xe as a security contractor? You could have 125,000 after a year and could keep coding when you're inside the wire. With that financial cushion things could be smoother.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by mapgrep on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:42AM (#3879325)
I read your story and I see someone who is full-time kicking ass to fulfill a true personal passion.

I see you've got various doubts. One small suggestion: when you say things like "I'm too old to compete at this gig" ask yourself if there is specific actual convincing evidence for that, or if you're just grappling with some near-term depressive thoughts. (Also, try gathering evidence for the opposite argument: That you'll compete well with your professional colleagues.)

I hope that didn't sound condescending. I definitely don't have any psychological training, just my .02. Having watched this industry for a while, I can assure you many of the people you think you're competing with will come and go with the business cycle and with real-world work challenges. People who really want to do it stick around through various bubbles and tend to do very well for themselves.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:18PM (#3879545)
I thought there was? I mean, I keep reading about the age bias of hiring someone cheap at 18 or fresh out of college at 23, and that seems like a deathly blow to my success probability. I'm 25 now, so if I continued on the same path I'm on today, I would be starting out at 28.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by mjcohenw on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:53PM (#3879757)
In three years you will be 28 no matter what you are doing. Better if you are doing something you like. (From Platitudes 3:14)
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by lbo on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:59AM (#3879419)
This may seem like another one of those trite responses you mentioned, but I would second the notion that "you can do anything you put your mind to" and that you should keep up the program, or at least keep learning CS on your own. If you look to put degree notches on your belt and list languages you know on your resume, you're looking at things the wrong way. Build things! Get excited about what you can build--anything! The more CS you know, the faster you can learn more. If you want to be inspired by some of the applications out there for your talents, try taking one of the awesome free courses at Udacity (or Coursera) and add Python to your list of known languages while you're at it. You can do them at your own pace (I would lump together 3 or 4 classes and just muscle through them when I had a free weekend) and learn from some of the smartest teachers out there.

Even in an elite university, programming isn't something that's taught to you. You teach it to yourself by doing and digging. What university can do is give some structure to what material you get through and ensure a higher level understanding of some of the concepts (and it's probably a better environment for learning the math and statistics that are useful for any computer scientist).

Anyway, don't defeat yourself and don't underestimate how critical this knowledge will be in 10, 15, 25 years when the world will be a whole new place filled with much much more software. The human mind is incredibly plastic and with the proper enthusiasm can be melded to serve nearly any purpose :)

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:25PM (#3879590)
I agree with you, and I would love to actually have the time to dedicate to such a focus. What ends up happening in reality, however, is the tradeoff between having a roof over your head, and learning. I'm not sure I'm well versed enough yet at being a civilian worker, and still having enough time to dedicate to learning what it is I want to know.

In other words, I look at your post and thing "YES, Great! I would love to do all those things!," when I come back down to reality and realize that I'll need to spend the majority of my time making slightly more than minimum wage to support myself, just to have a place to sleep. While some learning can be accomplished in the downtime, we both know it can't be done as fast or as efficiently as a full-time student's dedication.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by lbo on Tuesday April 24, 2012 @02:28PM (#3885573)
Some jobs are better suited to learning than others. Whether it's working at a public library, being a night-shift security guard, or any other job that would allow you access to a computer (having persistent internet isn't even necessary). What you can get away with is different at different jobs. If you're motivated, you'd be amazed how much you can learn on top of having a full time job--often much more than the average full-time student absorbs. Are you leaning more toward redirecting your learning toward something you can pick up more easily or toward giving up on higher education in general?
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by cmeranda on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:46AM (#3879338)
Yeah, the glamour goes quick, that's for sure. But when it goes it reveals the bones of the thing, and that can be good. A fast learner and thorough problem solver will find work in programming, IMHO, competition be damned.

Personally, I didn't learn very much in my college CS studies (incidentally, I was also in Marine Corps ROTC at the time at VA Tech). My cofounder, who studied at UCLA, whistles a very different tune, but I don't think his education has been a determining factor in his success as a programmer. I think that for me, the missing impetus was money: once coding became about a paycheck and an actual customer, that's when I began to love it. Pure theory just doesn't turn me on. You might consider that what you're lacking isn't education, but motivation: find a good problem to solve, and fill in the blanks of your skills from there.

All this to say, starting at a young age is not the sole determining factor of success in programming, and having a CS degree may not get you where you want to go. Recommendation: if it's possible for you financially, apply to a startup whose mission you find compelling, lie brazenly on your résumé, and take the risk of being fired.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by pirateking on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:17PM (#3879539)
Perhaps, try an alternate method of learning. Drop the course load, and instead think of some ideas that you really want to see happen (doesn't matter how trivial, or whether it has already been done). Then go make it happen.

Along the way you will definitely learn what you need to, and it should be a fun and rewarding journey. Using the free resources available on the internet, you may also pick up quite a bit of CS fundamentals and theory along the way, as well as see their practical application. When you show these hobby projects to potential future employers, your passion and motivation will definitely stand out, no matter how amateur the final result actually turned out.

It is scary to stray from the standard curriculum, and wing it. Who knows how things will turn out, what if you are doing things the "wrong" way, and you won't even have a piece of paper to show for it at the end. But that really is the most important difference between someone starting at age 12, and someone starting at 25 - the freedom to explore.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:35PM (#3879656)
I will check this out, thanks.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by thenonsequitur on Monday April 23, 2012 @11:54AM (#3879390)
The truth is, programming is honestly not so hard. It just seems that way to you because it's so easy to convince yourself of that. I want to emphatically remind you that it's not. You have to believe that it's not hard before you can get good at it.

And it doesn't help that programming courses, like much of school, sometimes suck the excitement and imagination right out of you while simultaneously instilling fear.

Forget that, and just start coding. Anything! It really doesn't matter what. The only way to get good it programming is to program a lot. It doesn't matter if what you make is good, well-written, useful to anybody (even yourself), etc. Find something interesting to you for whatever reason, and just start programming--start now and don't stop--and you will become proficient way faster than you realize is possible.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:28PM (#3879605)
I would absolutely love to dedicate the time to doing this the way I think, and know, it should be done (I taught myself html, javascript, early css when I was 11 because I thought it was fun, like everyone else my age probably... but I remember how it felt in comparison with what I'm doing now, and I know that teaching yourself through sheer passion was far more fruitful and entertaining.) Unfortunately, time ends up being the most precious commodity, and I'm not sure I've learned how to juggle that properly and still maintain a roof over my head, yet.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by epicviking on Monday April 23, 2012 @01:10PM (#3879839)
I was in a similar place two years ago.

Everyone around me totally out classed and outsmarted me. I made friends with a guy who was freelancing on the side for a local company. I offered to help him in exchange for some tips and help. He said yes. I learned a bunch of front end stuff, and took on some freelance work of my own. One of my projects impressed a local company I met at an event and that turned into a full time job doing Android Development. I got called by one of my 4.0 classmates just last week asking if I could help them find an internship. It's funny how these things works.

Hang in there man, keep your head down and don't be afraid to ask for help. Its a hell of a lot more attainable than you think.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by thyrsus on Monday April 23, 2012 @04:08PM (#3880694)
Just another story: I got my CS degree in '81 and I've been doing Unix sysadmin for almost thirty years. I always emphasize automation; right now we're moving our configuration to puppet. A couple years after I took my current gig, I was recognized as an irreplaceable single point of failure, and we looked for someone to share the knowledge. We hired an ex-Navy guy 10 years older than me. Why? He was the the only interview who claimed to know how to program. Picking him was the best decision I've made in this job, because he's self motivated and keeps learning, right along with me.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by Cariapa on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:27PM (#3879597)
It seems like you're kind of a jack of all trades. This is an awesome skill-set to have while working in a datacenter. Call it IT/dev-ops whatever.

The tech field isn't restricted to just people that code for a living.

I would ignore Norman Matloff. Some 15-20 years ago he wrote a series of articles claiming that H1-Bs, outsourcing etc would kill off the careers of all US programmers. That didn't happen as far as I can tell.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by biot on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:31PM (#3879629)
Personally, I wouldn't be focused too much on university and your age doesn't matter a whole lot. While a degree in CS is a nice feather in your cap, I've interviewed (and unfortunately had to work with) people who had the right credentials on paper, but couldn't program their way out of a wet paper bag. IMHO, there's only two things you need: passion and aptitude. If you lack either or both, perhaps being a programmer isn't the right career choice for you.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by doktrin on Monday April 23, 2012 @08:57PM (#3881884)
Build something. You are not too old. Ignore your own negativity.

I'm not writing this not as someone who's "made it", but as someone who will.

Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by seunosewa on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:14PM (#3879522)
You started out with the hardest programming language in common use. Bad idea. Start with Python and grow from there.
Re:Software Engineers Will Work One Day For English Majors by xenithorb on Monday April 23, 2012 @12:20PM (#3879565)
I initially did start out with Zed Shaw's book when I got out, but I was inevitably channeled into C++ because that's all colleges teach here. I guess they're a bit behind the power-curve, as always.