I respectfully disagree. Here are a few examples why:
- In my country 1 in 4 people are employed by the government. Their income does not come from 'customers', it comes from tax payers. Many large gov. contracts are won through corruption.
- The weapons industry makes money. It benefits from war.
- Paper/oil/meat/mining industries are huge, they're largely fed by non renewable and increasingly precious resources.
- The food industry is making money while systematically destroying peoples health and negatively shaping societies relationship with food.
- etc etc.
>"You don't get to be a millionaire by making people miserable."
How quickly we forget. The housing market crash was created by a whole swathe of people getting rich while making people miserable. Financiers rarely consider the consequences of their decisions, they think about the bottom line.
- Government provides services. Around here, it's healthcare, schools, universities, infrastructure, defense, a justice system, social services, plain governing, etc.
- The weapons industry might be an ethical negative, but they provide benefit to society in terms of basic research and R&D (not saying other things couldn't replace this -- I'm saying right now they provide this value)
- Paper/oil/meat/mining provides tangible goods that while depleting a finite resource pool still provides value today to scoitey.
- etc etc.
Actually this is another example of a rich person talking about how it's not about the money. You think weapons are intrinsically unethical, go and talk to the hundreds of millions of unarmed "ethnically cleansed" peoples in the 20th century.
Are they dangerous? Sure, no question. Ethically negative? A lot tougher call. All of those beloved government institutions are fundamentally built on there being a strong government, and when it is all boiled down, that fundamentally depends on having a government that can defend you against foreign incursion. If that is easy to forget, it is only because you are abundantly supplied with defense.
I find it hard to say any object is "intrinsically" ethical or unethical, but the arms industry certainly has a strongly culpable role in the outcome you're talking about. The genocidaires of the 20th century were massively more efficient than those of any previous century because they did killing on an industrial scale, with a lot of R&D behind it. And a lot of industrialists made a lot of money enabling it, sometimes working in close collaboration with the people doing the ethnic cleansing.
Note that I say that they might be an ethical negative, not that they are intrinsically unethical. But I believe for example that when Sweden exports weapons via middle men to Libya or Iran, that's a net negative. Also, boiling down the existence and services of "all of those beloved government institutions" to national defense seems very simplistic. Right now, there are a ton of factors beyond missiles standing between me and foreign incursion.
Gambling does not help society, and it is legal:
Buy a house for x, sell it to a fool that will pay 4x, who will sell it to a bigger fool for 6x. Now houses go back to x. The only problem is that the bigger fool is the normal American or European middle class that in not an expert on economics and it has been fooled will all their savings from experts with their own money(investment banks takes the money from banks because they are the same since it become legal).
You can say: "I can choose not to buy a house". But then bailouts happen and you pay for it.
Invest on a company, lets call it "makebook", x money lended from pension funds, "makebook" gives (1/10000)x profits a year, sell private stocks to bigger fools for 10x("internet""cloud","social" or any other magical word companies, are the future...), and let those sell again to bigger fools for 100x. Now the company make an IPO for $100B is never going to recoup, but middle class get crushed again.
http://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NASDAQ:GRPN
Also money printing makes a lot of money, it is the main way to "make" money in the world.
I mean I agree with you in what it should be, but a big part of the world does not work that way.
What if the movie sucked but the person didn't know it beforehand?
> You don't get to be a millionaire by making people miserable.
Why not? I can think of several ways. You could make them miserable first by advertising, them sell your product as a remedy. Or sell a positional good and let your customers have bidding wars, even though the total sum of misery remains unchanged. Or sell a good with large negative externalities.
HFT and Domain squatting are legal.
Not sure what's wrong with either of these, or why they are any worse than any other business that seeks to take advantage of market inefficiencies or speculate on asset prices (after all, most businesses are some combination of the two)
By holding it hostage and waiting for the highest bidder?
And "I take money from people to increase available funds for others' business purposes" is not much of an ethical argument, either.
>"You seriously should stop resorting to trite talking points and buzzwords"
Who's corroding the conversation? Keep it civil buddy.
Are you really trying to derail the discussion into a debate about HFT and domain squatting?
Do we really need to think of all the possible legal ways to make money that don't help society?
How about recognizing that the point of my comment is correct, even if you manage to find some legal way to make money that "doesn't benefit society"?
However, one thing I don't understand is why everyone keeps talking about industries that fall largely outside of the scope of Silicon Valley. This post seems to be directed at entrepreneurs (I would guess that most employees of SV tech startups are paid more than the rest of the tech sector anyway) and it seems counterproductive to steer the discussion in the direction of the finance, law, medical, or any other industry which are (I would think) drastically different situations.
There are many individual academics for whom it's not about the money, but this institutional culture corrodes altruistic motives, and selects against them.
For example, I made more at around five years in to working at Microsoft than I will as a professor unless I manage to make full professor at a top university _and_ run my own lab. Undergraduate starting salaries in this field, from top-tier institutions, are still far above assistant faculty salaries, despite ~8 years less education (a post-doctoral stint is basically mandatory to even get a faculty position interview at this point).
So, even if I made the very top tier of my field and stayed there until senility sets in, it's questionable whether I could ever make up for the lost wages during my re-education. And that's assuming I had never gotten another raise beyond inflation, ever.
At least in CS, you don't go into academia for the money.
I do think, though, that if the institution's executive goals are more along the lines of "make money" while an individual's are more "do cool stuff to change the world," he or she is setting himself up for an enduring conflict which can be hard to negotiate, or even to keep track of at times, because the institution will have so much influence over their life.
I agree that incentives are increasingly selecting for empire-builders, though, which is money-related. There are some people who really want to manage a big, important physics lab, and are more ambivalent about the physics itself, and those people are nowadays being selected for.
Further, many of these organizations arguably don't improve society. For instance, the Red Cross monopoly on blood supply significantly drives up health care costs, primarily to the personal profit of the Red Cross bureaucracy.
But this is all sidestepping my point.
The idea that making money is to the detriment of society is the claim I wish to dispel.
My point is not that you can't help society without getting rich-- its easy to prove you can.
My point is, most ways of getting rich do significantly benefit society.
The money you make comes from somewhere- generally customers who are parting with it. Why are they parting with it? Because they prefer what you're buying to the alternative.
People spend, in the aggregate, because it makes their lives better. Even hoarders drowning in needless stuff are spending the money to assuage the pain they would feel if they didn't.
The vast majority of software has a serious positive impact on the customers lives. We may wonder about Instagram, but instagram made a LOT of people happy. Making people happy is a positive benefit to society.
Plus, lets remember what money is. Money is a medium of exchange, its not the thing itself. It is a medium for trading your labor or your intellect. A ditch digger rents his body out at work in exchange for money. When he buys shoes, the money is simply they conveyance of the value from digging the ditch to the person selling the shoes.
When a software developer uses his brilliance to come up with a new program, he's trading his brainpower for whatever he ends up being with that money. Money is the medium that enables efficient transactions where barter failed. That's all.
Money is really another way of saying life.
People don't trade their life away, generally, except where it is profitable.
You make a billion bucks by making something people want? You've improved their lives probably by 7-9 billion dollars worth.
$7 for a movie? Worth more than $7 in entertainment to the person buying it... or they wouldn't buy it.
You don't get to be a millionaire by making people miserable.
(and I need to get a blog going, I think my comment is longer than the original article.)