Re:No last-minute reprieve, US ban on some Apple Watch sales...
by c0pium on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @02:10PM
(#38774892)
Those dates are all incorrect (or at a minimum not applicable). As is stated in the cited Wikipedia article, those dates are for detecting pulseox via transmission of light through a thin part of the body, such as a finger or ear, as opposed to reflectance. Reflection pulse oximetry from a thick part of the body, such as a wrist, is a much more recent invention and is the subject of these patents.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:No last-minute reprieve, US ban on some Apple Watch sales...
by withinboredom on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:58PM
(#38776537)
This. Is this it? "The scattered light through the tissue came back instead of through, so this is totally novel!"
Like literally, we are arguing over the vector of the light?
Re:No last-minute reprieve, US ban on some Apple Watch sales...
by c0pium on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:15PM
(#38776681)
Technically yes, but that’s a bit like saying rocket engine patents are about the vector of hot gasses. There are a lot of issues with creating one chip that both emits and receives light which are not present in a transmission model. In particular, if you look at the actual claims in the case, this is what many of the areas which were infringed upon deal with.
Re:No last-minute reprieve, US ban on some Apple Watch sales...
by az226 on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:31PM
(#38778452)
I think that has to be decided by jury/judge.
Re:No last-minute reprieve, US ban on some Apple Watch sales...
by c0pium on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:00AM
(#38779248)
What do you think this article was about, if not a judge and jury deciding this issue?
Re:No last-minute reprieve, US ban on some Apple Watch sales...
by withinboredom on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:00AM
(#38781162)
A rocket engine (in its entirety) is probably not something you'd patent, probably because of precisely this issue. A sensor that can detect light is also likely not patentable, even if how it does so is novel. That seems ridiculous to me; there needs to be a point at which a patent, no matter how novel, shouldn't be possible.
Maybe I'm wrong, but I'd love to be on that jury.