For individuals I don't think this approach works very well, but over a population I can believe it comes out in the wash.
That depends on your definitions. I'm not sure about U.K. reserve ratios, but in the U.S., about 90% of your bank deposit goes back out as loans that hopefully increase economic activity. The majority of that activity probably isn't carbon-neutral.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_requirement
In addition, banks in modern times have never had to wait for deposits to extend loans.
> In addition, banks in modern times have never had to wait for deposits to extend loans.
Are you referring to the discount window, the repo market, and interbank lending, or the fact that reserve requirements are typically averaged over a couple of weeks? In these cases, (as long as there's a reserve requirement), a person adding to a bank does still enable more lending, no? Or, are you saying that in modern times, even with non-zero reserve requirements, commercial banks usually operate with excess reserves, so reserves are not the limiting factor on lending?
> The reality of how money is created today differs from the description found in some economics textbooks
> Rather than banks receiving deposits when households save and then lending them out, bank lending creates deposits.
https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...
NS&I doesn't write loans, nor does it have a big vault full of cash somewhere, instead my money is "invested" in running the country I live in. Rather than borrowing money from international money markets by writing gilts (bonds payable by the government) they borrow my money and pay me interest.
As a result, nothing changes, all the same things were going to happen anyway, just they'd have borrowed from the Chinese, or the Americans or whoever was buying gilts.
It's definitely how it is used by activists / NGO etc tho [1].
Another strange practice is to scale the CO2 production with the price of goods. Eg: it is assumed that you produce 10x more CO2 when you buy a $100 bottle of wine than if you buy a $10 bottle of wine. This makes no sense at all from an environmental perspective, but the conclusion you can draw from this are aligned with the political views of the people producing those reports.
1: https://www.oxfamamerica.org/explore/stories/top-5-ways-bill...