Edit: No longer mentioning stuff that isn't essential to my post
Edit: I'm specifically disputing "And that's precisely what incubators like YC are out to solve; the issue of upfront cash flow to fund start ups." The post you were responding to just said that they don't do that well, at least if you have to pay a programmer (although the Start Fund would help with this.)
That's the point I got; it's pretty hard to fund a tech start up with a non-technical partner when there isn't a whole of money. Nor can a non-coder do it alone, because he would have to pay programmers. And I agree.
Edit: for civility's sake. Glad the internet allows take backs!
Perhaps not. But I think the premise behind the incubator is to allow coders with ideas to get them off the ground. Obviously, these founders are required to do the actual work. It's sort of a special case. I'm not even sure it makes sense from a non-technical standpoint. Has anyone ever been accepted to YC on a non-technical basis? I know Tech Stars accepted someone...that didn't end well.
It comes down to a difference in philosophy. I believe that, for a technical business, the founders ought to be directly responsible for the product creation (as in build-by-git and not build-by-Skype). I'd rather see technical/design skills win out over marketing and business hustle in the end (in terms of capital ownership). And I say this as a business major (who's exercising his coding and design muscles now).
Perhaps, but can you start a successful one? I'm guessing, no.
"I know, because I've done it "
What have you done, out of curiosity?
"He can be replaced, as can the programmer."
That's because he's a technician. When you're starting a business, you don't want technicians.
But you can run a software business without knowing how to write a lick of code. I know, because I've done it (okay, I'm not completely inept technically, and I have a keen interest in the industry, but I would never claim to be able to "code").
I think my main point, which I believe to have been re-enforced in this thread, is that programmers often believe they are, bar none, the most important piece of the puzzle. To me, that's arguable.
The auto mechanic is an important part of the car dealership, but he certainly isn't dictating to the owner how to run the business. He can be replaced, as can the programmer. The reality is, most "ideas" only need average abilities, and there are lots of average coders out there. If you're awesome and are doing awesome things code-wise and building amazing products, good for you. You deserve everything you're getting and maybe more. But for my projects, I just need a nice website or a simple app. If you want to flex your muscles to me because you've learned a skill I haven't, I'll pass. Just like you'll pass on a idiotic non-technical founder.
Anyway, this has probably derailed far away from what I and certainly the author intended. Let me just say that it's no accident that most programmers end up working for someone who has never written a line of code.