Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by analog31 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @01:10PM
(#38746473)
Indeed, when I took statistics in college, nearly 40 years ago, we proved Bayes theorem, and worked through several applications, so it could hardly have been regarded as controversial.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by tnecniv on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:28PM
(#38747274)
Bayes theorem is fairly elementary probability. It isn’t the part that is questioned in Bayesian statistics. Someone disagreeing with Bayes theorem would be like disagreeing with addition.
The controversial part is the methodology for statistical analysis built on top of it (e.g., you need a prior but where did that come from?)
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by winwang on Saturday December 23, 2023 @06:28PM
(#38749347)
Priors come from the barrel of a gun :P
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by Tomte on Saturday December 23, 2023 @03:26PM
(#38747858)
Bayes theorem shares a name with Bayesianism, but it is not specific to it. No frequentist would question Bayes theorem, it is on the level of 1+1=2.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by adastra22 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @01:24PM
(#38746587)
It’s not. Statistics is statistics. This controversy is new and contrived.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by jvans on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:42PM
(#38747419)
The controversy is decades old and largely resolved. Both methods work well on large enough data sets, Bayesian methods are far superior on small datasets
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by adastra22 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @05:36PM
(#38748981)
This statement doesn’t really make sense to me. A frequentist approach assumes a random (or noisy) underlying process and characterizes its probability. A Bayesian approach assumes a fixed but unknown process and updates the probability a given model matches that reality.
It is ultimately the same math, if you are comparing apples to apples. Just different ways of looking at a problem. Sometimes one is better suited than the other.
It’s like as if physicists were arguing over whether Cartesian or Polar coordinates were better. It’s the same damn physics, just expressed differently. In some problems one approach is easier to work with than the other, and can even make seemingly intractable problems solvable. But that doesn’t mean the other approach was “wrong.”
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense
by jvans on Saturday December 23, 2023 @06:05PM
(#38749206)
In many cases yes. A simple example where this is not true is if your populations have different variances. T tests are no longer valid but heterogenous variances can be modeled with a Bayesian approach