News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:They Want You to Forget What a Film Looks Like by gjsman-1000 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @09:40AM (#38744518)
If pirates were cared about preservation, they would not dare compress the rip from the disc.

And yet, they do. They throw away detail as they please. That’s preservation?

Re:They Want You to Forget What a Film Looks Like by FirmwareBurner on Saturday December 23, 2023 @10:03AM (#38744687)
Preservation doesn't always mean to preserve every raw bit or analog signal off the original medium, but preserve the content itself, even if compression is used, because certain niche movies never get re-released on modern medium, you're just left with the original Laser-Disk or VHS, maybe even DVD if you're lucky, and that's it, so compressed video is better than no video because you have no legal way of obtaining that content today if it's not sold on any physical medium or on any streaming service.

Compression is needed on torrent sites because few peers are interesting in downloading and seeding a 60+GB raw file of a movie if the 12GB mkv looks just as good on the 1080p Wallmart monitor.

There are of course also RAW rips of blu-rays out there but mostly for AAA IPs like Star Wars, LotR, Matrix, etc, not for niche content that have a reduced audience.

Re:They Want You to Forget What a Film Looks Like by NewsyHacker on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:22PM (#38747210)
If you think raw videos are available only for niche content, you have been missing out. BDRemux (i.e. not the Blu-Ray image with its menus but an un-recompressed repackaging of the video and audio into a .mkv file) is a common and decently well seeded format even for niche art films, from not only various private trackers but also the public Russian torrent tracker, with the hash carried along on other public trackers, too. Those 4k releases at 60GB or whatever are showing up, too.
Re:They Want You to Forget What a Film Looks Like by HumblyTossed on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @08:13PM (#38777944)
You can absolutely get straight disc rips.