They used to have 3 divisions, PDD-NOS, Aspergers, and Autism and thought that they overlapped and overlap was supposedly bad.
The root of the problem hardly seems to be pop culture, which to me has shown a pretty wide spectrum of autistic behaviour and generally portray it far more positively and heterogeneous than medicine does, which treats somebody having a diagnosis of Autism in the same light of them having a diagnosis of cancer. It's pop culture which has eased the stigma, it's high culture which truly looks down upon autistics as poor lambs to be saved.
When I was a kid, doctors were in love with emphasising how I would probabilistically never succeed. Meanwhile, Hollywood put out a bruce willis film about how autistic children are smarter than NSA cryptographers. I listened to Hollywood, and ignored the doctors.
I would love for people to move past talking about "Autism" and start talking more about anxiety, Social difficulties, digestive issues, obsessions, compulsions, and so on. If treating autistic people as homogenous is wrong to begin with, why is giving them all the same label a good idea?
That's a rhetorical question - the answer is that "Autism" became insurable, so ever since then there has been this pressure to describe increasingly diverse groups of people using the same label, and for people to NEVER lose this label. I had a psychiatrist re-diagnose me on the grounds that "Autism" had more funding than "Asperger's" at the time. I think pop cultures autistic savant obsession is just a reflection of this, and the root cause of nonsense portrayals and generalisations is money.
Maybe the confusion comes from „no two autists are alike in their symptom signature“ (which seems to be true), vs „most autism cases can be treated by X“ (which seems to be true at least sometimes). While it’s a highly individual syndrome, the metabolic and other causes could be more general. If that’s not the case - then we might actually need sub-syndromes, and I think this is actually WIP. Eg there‘s now pathological demand avoidance (PDA) which could, if it occurs outside of autism, become its own disorder.
"Autism" as a diagnosis sort of prescribes people be treated in standardised discriminatory ways from early childhood for their nominal best interests, rather than simply giving you a set of advice you can pick and mix from. This is likely to result in homogenous and harmful treatment in practice.
I'm also DEEPLY sceptical of autism I.E. clinically significant differences in social behaviour all being caused by some unified biological cause, given the decades long failure to find this smoking gun, my conclusion is that DSM-V categorisations are a social construction which don't map 1:1 with what is going on biologically. The more I learn about the sheer variance autistics really have in symptoms, and how we see clusters of symptoms like insomnia or digestive issues which don't even appear on the DSM-V at all, the more convinced I get that autism is really more than 1 thing. We even know about things like fragile X syndrome, which most autistics don't have, but which reliably causes a high incidence of autism. The project which seems to have the most momentum in overhauling DSM-V taxonomy is the RDOC framework. I honestly think that autism is multiple overlapping conditions is downright obvious, and I think the main reason it isn't taken more seriously is that Autism has become a useful brand.
Doing well in that sort of environment is a skill or disposition that's well-suited to a low degree of volatility and a high degree of predictable behavior, both of which are not so likely to be present in someone with autism. Seeing how people who become managers in tech fail to adapt to someone who works in a marginally different way than they'd like, I don't have so much optimism unless their superiors have specific training and possible accomodations.
Some autistic people are no-doubt brilliant and super productive, some can't do anything on their own, much like the general population I suppose, but I'd wager with a lower chance of being productive in a very typical office setting, even if they're brilliant.
It also seem to ignore the reality that relative to other domains, there's more autistic employment in cybersecurity and government than elsewhere. What exactly explains that, if autistics are supposedly so unsuited to the work, despite this apparent stigma in the form of this common sense view that autistics obviously can only uncommonly succeed at such work?
"The one thing that would be valuable to the NSA is autistic obsession with tech... ...You don't have to 'train' them, they'll train themselves"
"If you are an organization with zero skills of your own, then sure, hiring such kids will at least get you started. But you'll exhaust their value *within 3 months*, after which you've got a *sociopath* on your hands"
To put it another way, Autistics being good at hacking is nothing else but a matter of them doing extra training out of self-interest, but their inferiority is permanent. The reason why autistics get interested in tech is because they're innately good at technology leading to a positive feedback loop. They don't just wake up one day and decide to be obsessed about tech.
Such notions are why at my last employer I veiled my autism diagnosis. Which was not good for me, or for my employer, but what choice do I have? If I worked for this man, and I disclosed on day 1, he would fire me immediately or in month 3 due to his pessimism about my potential. Whereas if he found out later about my autism, he could slap his head and say I must be "socialised" and that he made a good hire. It would be in everybody's interest if autistics were open about their diagnosis, but could be confident they would be given time and support to understand corporate social norms they may have extra trouble understanding.
> NSA hackers are given specific tasks to achieve, they must play by the rules, and the paperwork involved is more arduous than the actual hacking. Such autistic kids would not do well in that environment.