News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by gentleman11 on Friday December 22, 2023 @01:41PM (#38737097)
> without inducing antibiotic resistance

Isn't that a way of saying "no bacteria can ever adapt to this method of killing them"? Won't at least 0.1% of them find a way to survive, and gradually adapt to this as well?

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by bawolff on Friday December 22, 2023 @02:03PM (#38737368)
I dont see why that would be true. The liklihood of adaption depends on the details of the method. Not everything is easily adapted out of.

Humans have been shooting each other with guns, and before that bows and arrows for a long time, and yet evolution hasn't provided us with fire-arm resitance yet.

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by acover on Friday December 22, 2023 @02:20PM (#38737553)
Another example: boiling kills most bacteria, very few have evolved to survive it.
Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by arrowleaf on Friday December 22, 2023 @03:08PM (#38738057)
I'm assuming the intended application of this is to kill bacteria colonizing a biological host. In order for that to work, the treatment needs to be selective in what it kills. If human/animal/plant cells have any mechanism to avoid being killed by the antibiotic, eventually the bacteria will adapt them.
Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by BobaFloutist on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:59PM (#38739607)
Humans take a much much longer time to evolve than bacteria (and much longer than we've been shooting each other), and your average human doesn't die to gunfire before they get to reproduce.

I'm sure if you put humans in an environment with a major chance of dying to gunfire before they reproduced for hundreds of millions of years or whatever we'd start to develop thicker bones or something - or just earlier and faster reproduction.

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by kulahan on Friday December 22, 2023 @01:50PM (#38737203)
>Cationic polymers are a promising class of bioactive agents, which trigger bacterial cell death through physical disruption of their membranes.

It sounds like it would be equivalent to humans evolving bulletproof skin. (quote is from their original paper which is linked in the article)

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by roughly on Friday December 22, 2023 @02:08PM (#38737438)
Yeah, and I think that's where the tension is:

- bacteria evolve much, much faster and over a wider range of capabilities than you'd think, so this is possible - hell, even probable - given the range of extremophiles we've seen

- for practical purposes, though, every adaptation comes with a cost, though, and the bacteria are not currently immune to this treatment because whatever they use for their membranes in absence of this threat is cheaper than something not vulnerable to this, which means this adaptation is disadvantaged where the polymers are not present

- the amount of time a bacterial colony has to evolve a response is basically limited to the amount of time it takes for a dose to kill the entire colony, which may not be long enough to reach a solution given the distance the genome would have to travel

- but, re: point 1, it's not guaranteed forever, which is why no scientist will say so

- but the media sure will, and for practical purposes may not be wrong

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by kulahan on Friday December 22, 2023 @03:24PM (#38738232)
The scientist in the article is quoted as saying that bacteria do not appear to develop resistance to this.
Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by hedora on Friday December 22, 2023 @07:50PM (#38740584)
That’s been true of pretty much every antibiotic at launch.
Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by teppic on Friday December 22, 2023 @02:04PM (#38737395)
> It sounds like it would be equivalent to humans evolving bulletproof skin.

You don’t need bulletproof skin if you can avoid being shot.

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by xaellison on Friday December 22, 2023 @01:52PM (#38737230)
"bacteria do not seem to develop resistance" - Dr. Quentin Michaudel

The press release is (predictably) more cavalier in its claim!

All this release says is that the polymers "[disrupt] the membrane of these microorganisms". At that level of detail, penicillin works similarly, and is vulnerable to resistance.

I'd love to know more detail about how this is a different kind of disruption.

Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by lainga on Friday December 22, 2023 @01:57PM (#38737298)
I thought there was a sort of "iron triangle" between antibiotics and phage therapy where bacteria couldn't maintain resistance to both. But OTOH phage therapy is several decades old and still rarely used
Re:Polymers capable of killing bacteria without inducing ant... by corethree on Friday December 22, 2023 @02:11PM (#38737469)
It's well developed and used by doctors in Russia I hear.