News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If the IRS had discovered the quadratic formula... by mikeash on Saturday April 21, 2012 @08:13PM (#3873432)
You appear to be using the word "regressive" to indicate both tax regimes where the poor pay more, proportionally, than the rich (which is what the word means in this context) and tax regimes where the poor pay less than the rich (which is called progressive). This is making it extremely difficult to understand what you're trying to say.

Why doesn't looking at tax / wages make sense in this system? The correct metric used to evaluate the fairness of a system doesn't depend on the system. It makes little sense to me that I would get net money from the government if I made $10 million in a year but managed to only spend $2,000 of it on taxable items (perhaps while spending the rest on non-taxed items like used houses and such).

Re:If the IRS had discovered the quadratic formula... by TomatoTomato on Saturday April 21, 2012 @11:58PM (#3873880)
Sorry for making the mistake, I would edit if I could.

You can metric the system however you want. It is just out of context under the FairTax to focus on labor wages. Warren Buffet only makes like 600k in "wages" and just pays the capital gains taxes on everything else he cashes out (or consumes). That's why is tax/earnings is so low. But calling the FairTax progressive by saying the rich who save/invest will be paying less is short-sighted. One can just as easily do this exact same thing with tax-deferred accounts or other complicated financial engineering today.

Yes, even if you make $10MM labor wages in a year, you will still get the prebate. Adding X,000 to your $10MM income will barely make a dent, but all citizens over 18? (I believe) will receive the prebate, similar to a social security check, and this can have significantly positive effect on the lower income bracket--especially coupled with the lack of withholding.

By the way, to say one can only spend 2,000 on taxable items is impossible. Even if you simply look at the "essentials"... food, clothes, utilities, insurance, & transportation, you will easily top $2k in taxable spending but that isn't the point.

If you spend all your discretionary income buying used homes, that is certainly your prerogative and would owe zero upfront tax on that purchase. You could just as easily put the money in a 401k type investment or any other tax-deferred account today and get the same effect. The current system uses a tax deduction and then the net income is what is used to calculate your tax. The difference though, is when you cash out that investment, you will pay the standard rate on the principle, but only 15% on the capital gains. Does that make sense? In the FairTax you will pay the standard rate on both the principle and the capital gains. The complexities would be gone. I think the bill itself is only around 100 pages. The high-priced tax accountants and lawyers won't be able to finagle P&L statements, establish irrelevant corporations to funnel money through, and lobby for special deductions.

Re:If the IRS had discovered the quadratic formula... by mikeash on Sunday April 22, 2012 @11:53AM (#3875118)
I'm not focusing on labor wages. I'm focusing on "income", which is, as you state, not the same thing.

I'm not trying to compare the FairTax to the current system. I'm simply stating what the FairTax proposal does. I don't understand how it's short-sighted to say that rich people who save/invest will pay less. It's a simple fact. One of the problems with regressive taxation is that wealth tends to snowball and this can be bad when the tax system perpetuates that effect. Why should a poor person pay X% on half his income because he has to spend half his income on taxed necessities, while a rich person pays 0% on most of his income which he spends buying up rental properties to rent to people like the aforementioned poor person? I'm not trying to say that investment like that is inherently bad, simply that this particular arrangement makes it very difficult for the poor person to get ahead, and much easier for the rich person to get even richer.

I'm not actually attempting to compare this system to the current one at all, so your continued criticism of the current system is off-base. I'm simply stating that the FairTax is fairly regressive, a feature inherent is essentially any system based heavily on sales tax, and this makes it deeply unattractive to me and a lot of other people.

Re:If the IRS had discovered the quadratic formula... by TomatoTomato on Sunday April 22, 2012 @09:08PM (#3876750)
I use the current tax system, because that's what I have to compare it to. The only other significant alternative is the Flat Tax, which is more regressive than the current system. Also, you say it is unattractive, but offer no alternative or rebuttal.

Yes, the top wage earners could pay less % in tax to their income than they do today, because there are more tax-deferred investment opportunities available. But again, tax-deferred investments, are simply that... deferred. The rental income would be spent unless it is re-invested, but again, no one saves into infinity and you have that same opportunity today if you really wanted to. Now, I haven't seen evidence of a income snowballing effect as you say though, but I would like to see it. In fact there is little debate on the overall economic impact, like one study that showed a 10% increase in GDP, real wages, and total employment plus a doubling of domestic investment after 5 years.

Again I ask for examples and data to discuss and look at. Studies using the Gini coefficient for example which is the most popular statistic of progressivity, show the FairTax as highly progressive. That number also rises even more if you raise the prebate base. We can certainly debate the merits of such a progressive system, but calling the FairTax "fairly" regressive because you believe it so based on your impression of sales tax systems shows that you are not well informed. There is study after study that shows that it is the most progressive tax system proposal.

BTW, an influx in rental home speculation will only drive rental prices down as more rental supply enters the market. Which is good for the lower income brackets.