News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Identifying and Eliminating CSAM in Generative ML Trainin... by goles on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @06:01PM (#38714802)
Obligatory IANAL, just lifting from the study.

> What actual difference is there between a machine generating this material or a human being drawing it by hand?

Page 8 Section 4 Legal concerns ———

U.S. Code[…]uses a standard prohibiting any visual depiction of CSA that is “virtually indistinguishable” from a minor engaging in sexual conduct. The definition it uses specifically references computer-generated material as being in scope.U.S. Code[…]states that any depiction of a minor that both contains sexually explicit conduct and is obscene can be prosecuted with the same penalties[...]

As such, the current status of CG-CSAM appears to be that prosecution is possible for any representation deemed both graphic and obscene,[…]if that material is indistinguishable. Now that CG-CSAM has reached the point that it may[…] test the application of some of these laws may be tested.

Realistic CG-CSAM also presents obvious difficulties when it comes to prosecutions for CSAM possession[…] in general, the appearance of a child being abused has been sufficient for prosecution[…]alternatives may need to be tested that do not require positive identification of a real-world victim (or worse, that would require such a victim or their family to testify)

> The answer may very well be "none at all,"

You may be correct but they do cite a number of counter-measures that will need to be tested and studied.

Re:Identifying and Eliminating CSAM in Generative ML Trainin... by Eisenstein on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @09:25PM (#38716319)
What is the rationale for prosecuting someone who has AI produced CSAM that isn't based off a real person?

The rationale used so far has been that it creates a market for production and revictimized the children. If this is not the case, what are we prosecuting people for exactly?