Re:YouTube loses court battle over music clips
by mattmanser on Saturday April 21, 2012 @05:39AM
(#3871394)
'ancient principle of common law'? Well thanks for the laugh at least.
According to you if I make and sell bombs it's unreasonable for a government to say 'make sure you don't sell them to nutters'.
It's a stupid argument. Of course there's a moral justification for such an edict.
Say I started a LOIC server tomorrow that people can use to attack websites. It's on EC2 so can scale wonderfully on demand. You think I can use your 'ancient principle of common law'?
I'm all for better delivery mechanisms, better competition, all that shit, but YouTube were making money off other people's hard work. They've always played with fire. YouTube even sailed close to the line of where things like gorrilavids are these days. At one point you could go on there and find pretty much any tv show you wanted. Do you know how you found them? Search for [series name] episode [x] series [x] or some variation like that.
Does that actually sound that hard to detect these with a simple automatic script? A bank breaking script? It's supposed to be user generated content, not ripped off content.
According to you if I make and sell bombs it's unreasonable for a government to say 'make sure you don't sell them to nutters'.
It's a stupid argument. Of course there's a moral justification for such an edict.
Say I started a LOIC server tomorrow that people can use to attack websites. It's on EC2 so can scale wonderfully on demand. You think I can use your 'ancient principle of common law'?
I'm all for better delivery mechanisms, better competition, all that shit, but YouTube were making money off other people's hard work. They've always played with fire. YouTube even sailed close to the line of where things like gorrilavids are these days. At one point you could go on there and find pretty much any tv show you wanted. Do you know how you found them? Search for [series name] episode [x] series [x] or some variation like that.
Does that actually sound that hard to detect these with a simple automatic script? A bank breaking script? It's supposed to be user generated content, not ripped off content.