News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by paxys on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @01:33PM (#38711980)
Here's a sensible way to make that transition – driving is treated as a privilege. If you are a dipshit on the road more than a certain number of times (driving drunk, running red lights, driving recklessly) then that privilege gets taken away, and you have to use an autonomous car. Over time the safety of everyone on the road goes up regardless of what they are driving.
Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by blitz_skull on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @01:39PM (#38712050)
That only works in parts of the world where there is a viable alternative to driving. Speaking as someone who has lived most of their life in the rural south US, that’s not a reality for most of the world.
Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by dcow on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @01:42PM (#38712079)
You missed:

> and you have to use an autonomous car

The idea being you use this hypothetical level 5 autonomous vehicle instead of the ones that let you be a dipshit.

Anyway, we already revoke peoples’ licenses for drunk driving and we do it in the areas you’re referring to.

Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by ttfkam on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @02:01PM (#38712284)
See earlier note about the public not accepting autonomous vehicles while they make errors humans consider nonsensical. The actual aggregated stats don't matter. The logic doesn't matter. All that matters is the video of a self-driving car veering off course suddenly and slamming into a school or bumping a pedestrian at high speed on video. It won't matter that no kids got hurt or that the pedestrian survived with minor injuries.

It will feel more dangerous and untrustworthy, and that has always been more than enough to kill a promising solution in this country.

If we can overcome that and actually follow the numbers instead of our guts, we won't need most of the cars in the first place—autonomous or otherwise—because the numbers say mass transit is the better option on all metrics: economic, environmental, safety, land use, etc. Cars are at best a backfill option.

Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by paxys on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @02:40PM (#38712684)
The general public doesn't have to accept anything because they still have a choice to use whatever car they want. It's only the drunk drivers being forced in those evil autonomous cars, and they would have otherwise killed themselves/others anyways if left on their own. And then over time the safety numbers, convenience and more will speak for themselves and convince you to switch.
Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by blitz_skull on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @03:10PM (#38713014)
Ah, you’re correct I did miss that. I’m not sure how I’d feel about a federally mandated solution like this… but I have to admit, it’s A SOLUTION to an otherwise big problem.
Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by MBCook on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @02:17PM (#38712450)
But what’s the point? Why do individuals need level 5 cars?

Why not just make tons of public transit at that point using the level 5 tech instead and cut traffic?

Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by sib on Thursday December 21, 2023 @03:46PM (#38726690)
>> But what’s the point? Why do individuals need level 5 cars?

Because there are places that public transit will never cover? I've been places in the American West that are 50+ miles from the nearest paved road, stop sign, or restroom. I don't think they're getting bus or train service any time soon.

Re:Waymo significantly outperforms comparable human benchmar... by mlyle on Thursday December 21, 2023 @11:17PM (#38730885)
No, but you could have public-rideshare in some of these places.

Level 4+ cars may be quite expensive for some time. Operating costs of L4+ vehicles will likely be low compared to human-driven vehicles (counting the cost of the driver). So, it could lead to car sharing in situations where we don't accept it currently.

> that are 50+ miles from the nearest paved road, stop sign, or restroom.

US population density is lower than most of the developed world, but what you describe is a tiny share of miles driven and can be effectively ignored for now.