Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by Modified3019 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:58PM
(#38704957)
It's beyond my current ability to evaluate if there's an error, but if so good catch. The contacts for the authors are on the following linked pages, I'm sure they'd appreciate correcting a mistake sooner than later.
https://www.ind.ku.dk/english/staff-auto-list/?pure=en%2Fper...
https://research.ku.dk/search/result/?pure=en%2Fpersons%2Fmu...
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by bee_rider on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @01:09PM
(#38711683)
Dimensional analysis just means checking that the units work out. You can do it!
x, dx, y and dy have units of length. dt has units of time. v, I’m guessing is velocity, so length/time.
length/length^2 = (length/time)^2 * length/time^2
->
1/length = length^3/time^4
These are different types of things, they can’t be equal to each other.
It is essentially like static types in programming, but for physicists, and it is a similarly simple but dramatically powerful idea.
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by pdonis on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @01:15AM
(#38705970)
> This paper has a pretty major typo in Eqn 11
Yes, the v^2 should be on the other side, as it is in Eqn 5.
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by kwhitefoot on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @03:50AM
(#38706635)
There is no excuse for that sort of thing these days when computational tools such as Maxima exist to check the dimensional consistency of equations.
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by cinntaile on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @04:48AM
(#38706937)
I can't find the homepage for Maxima?
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by jxf on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @05:01AM
(#38707019)
It's here: https://maxima.sourceforge.io/project.html
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by forgotpwd16 on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @06:19AM
(#38707425)
There wouldn't if the computer algebra step was integrated in the typesetting. Rather you first derive/verify the equations in a CAS and then write them in TeX for the paper. Even if export (like Mathematica) you may still decide to fix formatting a bit doing a seemingly obvious change which ends up changing the expression.
Re:Encouraging students to understand the 1D wave equation
by kwhitefoot on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @07:29AM
(#38707878)
A seemingly obvious change like moving a term from one side of the equation to the other?
Section II c tries to explain “the relationship between concavity and force” and concludes with:
> Then, adding a proportionality constant k and using dimensional analysis, we arrive at
d2y/dx2 = v^2 d2y/dt2
> which is the 1D wave equation
.. except dimensional analysis would say that equation has
m^-1 = m^3 / s^4
.. which makes no sense, until you realize they flipped dx and dt, and that isn’t actually the 1D wave equation.
Although to be fair, correcting author’s typos in textbooks was one of the more educational parts of undergrad for me, so maybe that’s secretly the point of the paper.