News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by jrockway on Friday April 20, 2012 @06:25PM (#3870070)
In the US, the police can take anything they want from you without compensation. For example, if you have a sports car and the police need to chase a suspect, they can take your car. If they crash it into a bridge and it explodes in a big ball of fire, that's your problem, not theirs.
Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by jessriedel on Friday April 20, 2012 @06:42PM (#3870125)
>In the US, the police can take anything they want from you without compensation.

I think you are mostly wrong here, and WALoeIII 2 is mostly right, but I wanted to add some detail.

Certainly, if the police destroy your property inadvertently while pursuing a criminal, they are under no obligation to compensate you. It's considered tantamount to the criminal having destroyed it (and so you might be able to seek redress from him). But, it looks like if the police commandeer your property, they do in fact have a responsibility to compensate you, a la eminent domain. The Straight Dope article has good details. Choice quote:

> In United States v. Russell the Supreme Court was faced with a claim for three steamers commandeered by military authorities during the Civil War. The Russell court found it obvious that "the taking of such property under such circumstances creates an obligation on the part of the government to reimburse the owner to the full value of the service." The court continued, "private rights, under such extreme and imperious circumstances, must give way for the time to the public good, but the government must make full restitution for the sacrifice." The court concluded that the obligation to make full restitution was based on an implied promise "on the part of the United States to reimburse the owner for the use of the steamboats and for his own services and expenses, and for the services of the crews during the period the steamboats were employed in transporting government freight pursuant to those orders."

That said, things aren't always so clear:

>The Supreme Court hasn't said what happens if equipment is borrowed and returned damaged, but lower courts have been reluctant to award compensation in such cases. In Blackman v. City of Cincinnati, for instance, the Ohio Supreme Court refused to compensate a vehicle owner for a crash that occurred when police ordered him to chase a fleeing suspect. Other courts have followed suit.

http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2247/can-cops-reall...

Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by michaelbuckbee on Friday April 20, 2012 @07:30PM (#3870241)
A Judge dismissed a lawsuit regarding a Ferrari that the Feds accidentally crashed while joyriding in it.

http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2011/10/11/feds-off-hook-for-...

Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by jrockway on Friday April 20, 2012 @06:47PM (#3870141)
I think the second quote was what was stuck in my mind when I wrote that comment. I knew I read about this somewhere; probably on The Straight Dope. Thanks for sharing the correction and context.
Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by WALoeIII on Friday April 20, 2012 @06:33PM (#3870099)
"In the US, the police can take anything they want from you without compensation."

This is an outrageous statement.

There are special exceptions to the law, but the 4th Amendment of the Constitution explicitly protects citizens from illegal search and seizure.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United_...

Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by sedev on Friday April 20, 2012 @08:00PM (#3870319)
Sure, that's the law - but that is not the practice, that's not the facts on the ground. The moral panics over drugs and terrorism have expanded police powers such that it is de facto possible for the police forces to just steal from you. It's not legally theft: they've just redefined it, basically. It's similar to how the US government just effectively says "the things we do aren't torture, because we're doing them, and we condemn others for doing these things because they're torture."

If you have money, you have some recourse - but if you're an average citizen, the police can with any sort of drug- or terrorism-related charge, even if you are acquitted or the charges are dropped, de facto steal your shit and not reimburse you at all.

Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by gergles on Friday April 20, 2012 @09:11PM (#3870485)
You can quote the 4th amendment all you like, let me introduce you to what they actually do if you have something they would like: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_forfeiture
Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by vacri on Friday April 20, 2012 @08:24PM (#3870370)
That's not all that protective when it comes down to it - all you need to do is redefine what 'unreasonable' means in law.

It's 'unreasonable' and not 'illegal' by the way - and the latter would be even easier to get around, because you just legislate 'this is legal now', no semantic tricks required.

Re:Megaupload Trial May Never Happen, Judge Says by njharman on Friday April 20, 2012 @10:21PM (#3870650)
> illegal search and seizure

Yes, exactly. That is why so many outrageous search and seizure laws have been passed, thus making them legal.