News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by PreInternet01 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:16PM (#38698374)
Oh, come on. It's a high-pressure situation, where they're damned if they don't offer any AI plugins (why are you not as good as X???), and they're damned if they do (why is this freemium crap polluting my otherwise nag-free freeloader experience?)

Things will take a while to settle. Unless your workflow is *truly* broken by the fall-out, save your outrage. And yes, I'm a paying JetBrains customer, don't like their AI offering, but don't really like anyone else's either, so far...

Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by Lt_Riza_Hawkeye on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:18PM (#38698411)
Sure, but you should at least be able to uninstall the plugin. According to the thread it reinstalls itself on each launch
Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by PreInternet01 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:23PM (#38698466)
That seems like a minor bug at most? And if the plugin remains enabled, but doesn't do anything, what's the actual issue here?

Rephrased: what's the problem with waiting until the next point release of the affected product before assuming malicious intent?

Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by mystiick on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:30PM (#38698573)
A plugin that reinstalls itself to ask for money is malicious intent
Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by PreInternet01 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:36PM (#38698660)
Counterpoint: if you click once (per product install) to dismiss the "ask for money", then don't touch anything related to the plugin again, you won't hear from it thereafter.

Are we really equating poorly-coded add-ons to malware now? And again, I ask this as someone who lived through the whole broken experience of AI previews in JetBrains products and ignoring all of that. That literally took me less time than typing this comment...

Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by insanitybit on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @04:30PM (#38701920)
You're saying "a thing that happens is intent" it's literally nonsensical.
Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by ilc on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:34PM (#38698641)
Because the whole way they've handled this situation reeks.

Oh, we'll get you on a wait list. Bullshit. Waitlist never came in.

It's OK to say the waitlist closed. Keeping people hopeful is a shitty move.

Then to pull this on launch... (sigh) I didn't want to have to waste time on this shit. I'll go back to VSCode, neovim or whatever if I must.

I'm more frustrated with myself that I trusted them to provide me a year+ of quality service... and that isn't happening.

Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by PreInternet01 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @12:40PM (#38698716)
Believe it or not, but I lived through the whole broken experience of AI previews in JetBrains products by... just ignoring the whole thing.

Sure, I got "sign up now!!!" buttons that did nothing for me. I learned after, like, the first 3 times of clicking these not to do that again.

Then, I was, at some point, able to sign up for the preview. It was underwhelming. Like most other offerings in this space.

Meanwhile, all the core IDE functionality continued working as before... And all was good...

Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by donmcronald on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @04:40PM (#38702056)
If it's a feature people want, why does it need to be bundled? Won't people seek it out if it's so amazing?

That's a rhetorical question. I know the reason. If they don't bundle it, engagement will be low because people simply don't want it. At best, it's an advertisement in my IDE. At worst it's something that can send my code to an external party.

Re:JetBrains forces AI freemium plugin that cannot be comple... by mardifoufs on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:01PM (#38704974)
But even Microsoft does not force GitHub copilot. None of the competition to Jetbrains does it either.