On the other hand, federated services like Mastodon really work fine in the same way old school forums and personal sites did; the community decides what's acceptable, and content that goes against that gets blocked/removed.
The real issue is that moderation doesn't scale; you can't easily automate it if you want it to work well, and hence both large centralised networks like Facebook and Twitter and large decentralised ones struggle to keep things under control.
That's why it's so concerning to me that Mastodon admins can interfere with your ability to leave an instance. Like email, you're to an extent dependent on your old provider to forward.
But sadly that's gonna be a problem with instances of any size. If Twitter or Facebook or Instagram close your account, your data is probably just gone as well.
Add this to the difficulties of finding people that good in the first place (even more so said people willing to work for a large company and moderate at scale), and you've got a bit of a problematic situation:
- If you try to hire 'quality' moderators, then you likely spend millions of dollars a year on moderation, without any real guarantee that the moderation will actually be good (since different communities and groups disagree on it, cultural differences come into play, etc) - If you try to outsource the moderation to some low cost region, then you get poor quality moderation due to cultural differences and a lack of understanding of the subject matter and community. - And if you try to automate it, you arguably get an even worse situation, since false positives and negatives are everywhere and often there's no way to appeal the situation when they get things wrong.
Then things get even worse when you realise that different communities interact and have different standards...
Moderation is one problem of gray area, there is never a clear line between what is acceptable content and what isn't. Not only is the community and their opinion on what's acceptable changing, the moderation rules are a moving target and at scale you inevitably have government pressure to moderate certain content that the government doesn't approve of.
From every attempt I've seen tried over the years in tech, moderation is a losing battle and the main reason building large platforms for user-generated content is such a nightmare.
Mastodon tried this, specifically with federation as an attempt to decentralize. As long as people try to use it similar to a centralized platform like Twitterz the moderation problems only get worse. You end up with more moderators with less accountability all trying to moderate both their smaller circle and everything from the outside world too.
The only way I see fixing it with a different network model is by going for a fragmented system. Think 90s era forums, very group is its own small bubble and is never attempting to he part of some unified global town square.
Moderation can be done in a decentralized way. Email spam filters are an example of that.
I remember when CmdrTaco left slash dot. The place went to ruins almost immediately.
If dang didn't do what he did or someone like him, we would all probably leave here as well.
Joel Spolski managed to create a self-moderating site in stack overflow.
Say what you will about the platform being toxic, and you're not wrong. Content from the uninitiated is not treated well, but on the other hand, The quality of the content is generally very high. People have a lot to say about this, but I will remind them that self-moderation like what stack overflow achieved is a monumental achievement! This is a really hard problem!
In the early years of Mastodon the moderation wasn't so up to scratch as it is now. It has gotten so much better. It does give me hope that moderation can still be done on a decentralized platform. That said, it can't be denied that Mastodon is fighting in uphill battle precisely because it is decentralized when we speak of moderation.
Once we start to have more mature tools around moderation in the face of decentralization, I think we'll start to see a groundswell of decentralized services finally coming out of the shadows. We see this starting to happen already.