Re:RFC 9518 – What can internet standards do about centralis...
by j4yav on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @07:17AM
(#38694645)
I was there, AOL was certainly not the internet.
It's an interesting article but it seems to cherry pick a bit. AOL was like a huge BBS that gave its users a limited portal into the internet, and only on a very limited basis starting in 1993. They never really had proper access as far as I know, and for those of us not accessing through AOL things worked perfectly fine and I never accessed anything through or hosted by AOL.
I'm not really sure how to convince you in the end, but it's funny now hearing my own experience was only a legend. I feel like I've achieved something and need a plaque indicating I've successfully moved into some new life phase.
For a common example that many people may remember, AOL was at one point pushing towards a centralised model and was succeeding- until they completely collapsed and the open web resumed being a thing.
Similar for the times where there were no standards on video playback on the web, a bunch of companies competed with completely incompatible systems that had various pains associated until eventually standards emerged that sunk the majority of it. (ironically one of them with a healthy helping from Apple).
The web was never really decentralised - it's a fond memory and a legend we tell ourselves, this battle seems to been waged from almost immediately after it was conceived.
I found a much more articulate article on the matter while I was writing: https://archive.is/UUgl7