> but different in the same way that all the others already differ among themselves
I’d argue it’s different in a very different way. The conceptual gap between AI and traditional forms of art is arguably much wider than the gaps/differences that already exist between traditional forms.
Using mental models to reason about AI art that liken it to those older forms can be misleading. I do agree that it’s a new form that will carry its own properties and to which people will ascribe different kinds of value. Whether or not that ascribed value is deserved is another question - a question that must be raised because again, someone with artistic skills was still required to create the AI output, they’re just long forgotten by the time the image is generated.
If nothing else, the massive unanswered ethical questions raised by the use of models that can only exist because of the content created by traditional artists puts this firmly in its own category.
The value is literally not intrinsic, it is extrinsic and specifically socially/culturally ascribed.
And, yes, that's also true of different forms of art; while all have value, the kind and degree of value in any particular society of sculpture vs. representational oil painting vs. abstract oil painting vs. photography vs. 3d-rendered digital art are all different (and the difference between them aren't constant between times and places where they are present, either.)
Yes, art produceed using, e.g., diffusion models will be different from all the others in this regard, but different in the same way that all the others already differ among themselves.