News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by kazinator on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:44AM (#38679598)
> I don't think the type of person who uses invidious is going to ever be convinced to buy something from an ad on YouTube.

That user is using YouTube resources, without being of benefit to YouTube.

Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by AlchemistCamp on Monday December 18, 2023 @07:09AM (#38681458)
They still are a benefit to YT in that they’re strengthening YT’s network effects and not helping a fledgling competitor hit a critical mass of videos, comments and viewership.

MS and Adobe had similar logic for not going after piracy very hard in certain markets. They wanted users on their platform, even when they couldn’t get them all to pay.

Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by kazinator on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:35PM (#38685570)
Invidious is a essentially a fledgling competitor, which uses YouTube's video storage. Invidious users are not on the YouTube platform. Or maybe have one toe on the platform, or something like that.

YouTube is by far the dominant video hosting platform in the world; I'm guessing they probably don't feel they require the network effects from alternative systems that bypass their UI and API. They provide a site and app that are used free-of-charge by billions, and get all the network effect they need from those.

If going after piracy of locally installed software were comparably simple, easy and cheap, similarly to blocking an IP address, everyone would do it. Mainly it's not done against individual users because it's prohibitively expensive. Once the users have defeated the anti-copying measures in the software executables, they have gotten away with it. You'd have to send cops to their house to seize the warez.

Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by smashah on Monday December 18, 2023 @08:13AM (#38681955)
I subscribe to YT premium and sometimes like to use invidious so you're actually wrong.
Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by kazinator on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:54PM (#38685846)
I don't think there is an easy technical way (even if there were a will) to make an exception for Invidious users who have Youtube subscriptions. Invidious doesn't even use the Youtube subscription model in the first place. I'm guessing it's the instances that are blocked, not individual users using those instances.

The hypothesis that Youtube Premium subscribers might be using any given Invidious instance, so it's a bad idea to block it, is rather weak.

Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by calamari4065 on Monday December 18, 2023 @07:16PM (#38690197)
Generate an API key for premium users, add auth-only API to pull videos, user pastes key into their client of choice.

Even easier, one click oauth to automagically give the key to the client.

It's trivial.

Re:YouTube is trying to block Invidious by smashah on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:41AM (#38692926)
Yep, I think people have amnesia about the last 10 years where our API rights have slowly but surely been taken away and have a lack of imagination for solutions so fallback to authoritarian narratives.

API key so premium users can use invidious makes total sense - it makes creator revenue attribution more accurate also.

As a paying user to any service I should have the right to interop with whatever client or third party service I want.