This mirrors my experience. About six months ago, I had an accident on the metro in my city, where my leg slipped between the train and platform while deboarding. Not only did passers by not help, the "operators" stood idly by. While I am lucky to have escaped with "just" an ACL tear, I would have lost my leg that day if my friend hadn't been there to pull me out.
Come again? Seems like the latter disproves the former. After all, if people are so great, why would they build a machine that proliferates suffering?
What kind of man builds a machine to kill a girl? A smart one.
"Smart" does not imply good, nor virtuous. Merely capable.
ok, maybe? i don't think that's unanimously true
> Machines should be beside us, to help. Not between us and stop us from fully interact with each other.
and who puts them there and uses them as such?
who comes up with things like DRM'd juice packets?
people anthropomorphize machines:
"the car rolled over and crushed..." or "the train doors closed in his face"
No. "the reckless driver rolled his car..."
"the uncaring conductor closed the doors in his face"
"the bureaucratic corporation and engineers designed the train leaving no way to override the doors by the operator"
not as romantic, but closer to the truth.machines, computers included, are simply powerful levers. they amplify forces applied - good or evil or dehumanizing - by their users. nothing more.
not all people are good, and when those people use powerful machines to amplify their intentions, it can have enormous negative effects.
I get your point. Some people seem to be thriving. Yes, but those don't suck. The ones that are thriving and do suck are, in the end, succumbing to the increasingly dehumanizing environment.
> and who puts them there and uses them as such? > who comes up with things like DRM'd juice packets?
We do. People do. Yes. Those people suck. They are not ok and are clearly succumbing to the increasingly dehumanizing environment.
> people anthropomorphize machines:
Oh yes they do. Excelent point! In the end, it's all people. I totally agree. We cannot let responsibility die as an orphan. Those people suck, but ... well, you know, they "suckumb" ;).
> machines, computers included, are simply powerful levers. they amplify forces applied - good or evil or dehumanizing - by their users. nothing more. > not all people are good, and when those people use powerful machines to amplify their intentions, it can have enormous negative effects.
Yes. Without any doubt. We need to counteract that. Let's work together. We can!
"It is inevitable that we face problems, but no particular problem is inevitable." - David Deutsch - The Beginning of the Infinity.
I'm not generally a litigious person (at least I hope not), but that sounds like a law suit...
It's one thing to refuse to open the doors just to let a latecomer on board, but it's quite another for a person in a position of authority (and I would argue with a duty of care) to harm someone or put them in danger like this.
"We become what we behold. We shape our tools and then our tools shape us"
It's not just the machines that are ruthless. The operators also take on attributes of the machines they manage and in the process inflict willful cruelty on others through their control of the machinery. The most obvious example of this is, of course, war and the technology associated with its execution. So this essay is right, machines/algorithms are ruthless but it is the people that use them to inflict pain and suffering on others that makes the whole thing into a grand tragedy.