Think of how much users have been benefiting from new and innovative webapps, which are a result of the competition between browsers. Now imagine where we would be if Windows was a walled garden and didn't allow competing applications, like Apple does with iOS.
Openness breeds competition. Competition is always good for the user.
You get the best of both worlds with iOS without the pain of fragmentation and virus/malware/spyware/etc.
I'm not saying walled gardens don't have advantages to the users - a garden with a good landscaper is probably better for the common user, no doubt. But to say that openness only benefits devs and a small number of users is shortsighted. It's a balancing act.
also: iOS is open enough for 99% of the smart phone users.
I don't hear my mom complaining "oh how I wish i can install a custom boot ROM on this iPhone".
This is like saying that the average user doesn't care about free markets or not. Sure, they might not directly state a preference, but they do most certainly care about the platform benefits of it.
Having a walled garden is beneficial to 99% of the users.
"open" mobile devices (even though they really aren't that open) benefits some developers and users.