[1] Getting into a knock-down-drag-out with the new honcho overseeing CoreOS about us "doubling down on user privacy" was one of the last straws for me. Everybody in the audience was source-disclosed (and some of us had even read the relevant parts :), and the guy had the audacity to claim a certain thing was impossible when we knew that particular thing was not only possible but was being uploaded to the mothership ...
Apple have done a lot of work in relation to privacy, and I am struggling to think of times they have bashed Google in relation to that work. It’s rare for Apple to refer to competitors at all.
For instance, here’s Apple’s documentation on tracking prevention in WebKit:
https://webkit.org/tracking-prevention/
This is clearly the result of privacy work spanning many years. I can’t think of a time Apple have bashed Google in relation to any of this functionality.
This goes for pretty much everything I can think of where Apple is clearly working on privacy-improving measures. If the only reason Apple works on privacy is to bash Google, where is all the Google bashing? Because I can see a lot of privacy work, but I can’t see a lot of Google bashing.
I honestly could not care less what the marketing spin was; internally, we were being told things that we knew to be false.
I'm speaking specifically about the "absolute technical impossibility of providing certain information residing in the iDevice to anyone, even when the request was accompanied by a search warrant", which was the mantra circa 2014. The market differentiator was "we care about user privacy, in stark contrast with Google, who monetizes all data on their devices".
That was horseshit, as a specific security team regularly handled exactly those requests ... and heaven help you if you pointed that out in any discussion with management.
Things look a lot different from the inside.
(edit: s/piracy/privacy/)
Apple has plenty of lawyers. If they honestly didn't agree with this practice they could have politely told the feds to f$#& off. The fact that it took public reporting to make Apple feel safe discussing this means that (a) they did know (2) they didn't stop it and (d) this could pretty easily be little more than PR cleanup.
And would this be the only thing they did not realize or there is still a giant list f things that require to be made public until Apple realizes that those things are incompatible with their PR about caring about the customer privacy.
Maybe is time that Apple customers demand Apple to disclose what other data is released to authorities without a warrant and why is Apple not attempting to fight back against that.