News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Smoking Causes Cancer by gweinberg on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:27PM (#38620948)
The idea that there's some confounding factor isn't in itself implausible, but a factor of 16 increase in risk is huge. Of course, to really be sure you should also look at how lung cancer risk and smoking correlates between countries, and within a country over time. And you can segment the population by sex and ethnicity. Oh and also look for a dose-dependent effect, very important. Heavier smokers should be at a higher risk.

Of course, the link between cancer is smoking is even stronger if some of the "non-smokers" were exposed to an increased level of cigarette smoke.

Re:Smoking Causes Cancer by robwwilliams on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:26PM (#38621459)
With Mendelian randomization a genotype can be used as an instrumental variable if it is causally linked to the trait (usually as part of a genome-wide “association” study)—lung cancer in this case. this can provide reasonable assurance of causality. See Book of Why.