Re:RubyGem is from Mars, AptGet is from Venus
by FooBarWidget on Thursday December 04, 2008 @07:53PM
(#386431)
Maybe that's because the "security concerns" don't really explain what the actual concerns are, but only claim that they exist? If "RubyGems is a security hazard, I won't tell you why but it is so and if you disagree then you're an idiot" isn't FUD then what is?
Re:RubyGem is from Mars, AptGet is from Venus
by davidw on Friday December 05, 2008 @02:41AM
(#386783)
It's a security hazard because it's an entirely different update channel for security updates, as well as a second system that runs with root privileges and installs things from other people. It is not an immediate threat, but it is worrisome.
With apt-get, you have one thing to keep up to date in order to keep your system secure. It's so easy that you can automate it if needs be. It's also easy to keep track of security updates. With 'gem', now you have two things to keep track of.
I currently use apt-get along side the gem stuff to maintain my servers, but it's something I do worry about. I have no hesitation about trusting my servers to Debian or Ubuntu, but gem isn't quite so much a known quantity, and furthermore, I'm not sure the update system distinguishes between security updates and "hey, there's a new version of Rails (or whatever) that might break a bunch of stuff".
It's not an easy problem, that goes without saying, but I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss either side.