News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 18, 2012 @05:10PM (#3860238)
But you see businesses aiming for improved productivity all the time. A desire for full employment is just the national version of that. It's not like a country can easily or ethically fire or cut adrift swathes of its citizenry at once.
Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by gaius on Wednesday April 18, 2012 @05:45PM (#3860389)
Not really. Let me give you an example. In the 1980s, it was costing £70/ton to mine coal worth £40/ton. Labour party policy was that jobs for their supporters were more important than creating wealth for the whole country. In the end, raw economics forced a resolution - the country couldn't afford to double everyone's energy bill just to score some ideological points.
Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by Klinky on Wednesday April 18, 2012 @07:16PM (#3860692)
Thatcher's anti-union stance & unwillingness to negotiate with the coal union when on strike eventually lead to the industry's demise. If your view was that domestic UK coal production was a waste of money, then you can thank the Thatcher run government for shutting it down. Government can do good & bad depending on where you stand.
Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by gaius on Thursday April 19, 2012 @07:41AM (#3862444)
If Scargill had said "give us the means of production and we will demonstrate the superiority of collective ownership" then that would be one thing. The mines were costing twice as much to run as they were worth; the unions could have "bought" them for one pound! But that's not what happened. He said "just give us money". It's impossible to negotiate like that.

Incidentally, I never understood why Thatcher was evil for not subsidizing the loss-making mines, and modern politicians are evil for subsidizing loss-making banks (i.e. RBS).

Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by Klinky on Thursday April 19, 2012 @10:47AM (#3863239)
I do not think there could have been any way to make the industry profitable on the open market. Subsidies from surrounding governments were much higher for their domestic coal than the UK was willing to pay for theirs. Cheaper easily mined coal imports from Australia, Russia, South Africa along with North Sea oil & gas flooded alternatives on to the market. The fact that the assets were privatized and sold off later, yet the UK coal industry remained mainly dead along with the "green movement" probably shows that the industry could not have survived on it's own without the subsidies.

Some view Thatcher destroyed the industry not only because it was unprofitable but also as an attack against the unions, supposedly going so far as to shutdown even profitable mines or those that had potential. Putting 180,000+ out of work is going to cause some outrage from those you are putting out of work & the surrounding communities that relied on those wages. Also some may view domestic energy production as a valuable asset to retain even if it is not market viable just due to energy security/independence concerns.

As far as the bank comparison, I think some people have a kinder view towards the plight of a coal miner working in dangerous conditions for not a lot of pay vs the plight of an executive banker raking in massive bonuses while tanking the economy.

Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by gahahaha on Wednesday April 18, 2012 @06:21PM (#3860550)
It wasn't raw economics, it was politics. Thatcher saw that the miners helped bring down the Heath government, saw an opportunity to break the unions and consolidate her power. (Creating the insane social and economical inequalities in the UK today)
Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 18, 2012 @06:08PM (#3860494)
Sure, but you could find similar examples of companies extracting economic rents to benefit their shareholders until they were disrupted by a more agile competitor. My underlying point is that citizens are more like shareholders than employees, you can't just fire them because you don't like their demands. Governments are instituted to secure the interests of theri citizens, who then compete among themselves for control of institutions.
Re:Why The US Can Beat China: The Facts About SpaceX Costs by excuse-me on Wednesday April 18, 2012 @06:33PM (#3860584)
Now we rely on buying gas from Russia while spending £25Bn on Trident to protect us from Russia.