Re:User Interface Typography
by chrismorgan on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:23AM
(#38599982)
I don’t object to using a defined scales. Please have one; please. But I object to modular scales for the reasons I mentioned in the linked thread: they’re presented as virtuous, but they actually produce arbitrary, bland, inferior results, mediocre at best. It’s like some of the “golden ratio” guff people go explaining things with: it sounds nice, but it’s just plain nonsense. Therefore I will viciously attack modular scales as a concept every time I come across them (unless otherwise occupied). Someone’s wrong on the internet, and they’re misleading others.
I'll just address your strongest point about modular scales. Its redeeming quality is that it provides a predictable scale and aligns everyone on the team about text sizes. There is some dubious benefit about "harmony", and in the final paragraph the author acknowledges that this system can be ignored. There's no need to be so adamantly opposed to it, though.