News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by tw061023 on Monday December 11, 2023 @01:09AM (#38598082)
Writing a book on a topic is an art unto itself. Even most technical books have a coherent narrative, carefully crafted to bring the reader from point A to point B.

If you want a quick reference on a well-known topic, then sure, use an LLM. Or a search engine. Chances are it will even answer you correctly (but also chances are it won't, and if it is a new topic for yourself - strap in, you're in for a ride).

But if you want to really understand something, then you will have to do your research, and a lot of this research has already been summarized into tangible artifacts optimized for your consumption which LLMs would never be able to replicate.

Even if you can convince one to regurgitate a book verbatim, the narrative thread would be lost unless you weave it yourself with your prompts - but would you, the learner, be able to do re-enact the narrative better or even on the same level than the original author who posessed the knowledge on the topic?

Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by Shugarl on Monday December 11, 2023 @02:53AM (#38598526)
> but would you, the learner, be able to do re-enact the narrative better or even on the same level than the original author who posessed the knowledge on the topic?

Maybe. The author needs to write in a way that makes the book digestible to most people. Prompts allow me to get a version that's tailor-made for me.

Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by mFixman on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:36AM (#38598722)
Agreed completely.

LLMs are making the quick jot to Stack Overflow obsolete, which solves your immediate problems using the least amount of brainpower.

They are also making reference-style documentation and long-form books more important than ever, since you still need to learn things and correct your own knowledge biases.

Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by ChatGTP on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:51AM (#38599104)
LLMs are making the quick jot to Stack Overflow obsolete

Not for me they're not.

Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by Engineering-MD on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:44AM (#38599739)
Why would you say you still use stack overflow?
Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by ChatGTP on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:25AM (#38600422)
Because lift isn't a popularity contest?
Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by Engineering-MD on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:36AM (#38600985)
Do you mean lift the framework or are you referring to something else?
Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by EE84M3i on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:06AM (#38601258)
ChatGPT (3, I'm on the wait-list for 4) is fine at answering questions and coming up with code samples for stuff that's on the beaten path (hey, how do I do this in python or go). I don't have many of these sorts of questions.

I've found it to be wholly inadequate at answering the kinds of questions I do have a lot of - stuff like "How to watch a list of objects using kubernetes controller-runtime?". The answer I got is entirely hallucinated.

For those I find myself still searching GitHub for example code and sometimes using stack overflow.

Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by lacrimacida on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:07AM (#38599175)
For most people they are though
Re:Ask HN: Is ChatGPT making tech publishing obsolete? by ChatGTP on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:26AM (#38600432)
"Most people" do a lot of stupid stuff, I don't really care what everyone else does. Because the majority of people do something is absolutely no justification.

At one point in time, > 50% of people used to smoke cigarettes too.