I personally agree with the downvotes - I don't want to see every HN post littered with "this is what GPT-4 has to say about this".
I understand the aversion against „AI spam“, but I find it weird that a supposed tech community rejects AI tech wholesale.
Clearly labelled as LLM generated and used to summarise a long RFC (where I personally didn’t find the abstract as clear as GPTs summary).
But everyone will have their own views on this. There is definitely a lot of anti-AI or anti-LLM scepticism or denial on HN.
I don't trust current LLMs to correctly summarize complicated and nuanced text. Now, if someone with the relevant expertise wanted to carefully read an article, feed it into an LLM for a summary, verify its correctness, and post that, I'd be alright with it.
Or if the summary is interesting in some other way - like is it super wrong? or does it make interesting leaps? or maybe it is startlingly correct? - then sure, share it, but also share why it's interesting.
But sure, they could have just posted that instead of going through GPT. Doesn't really matter much imo.
It's easier to downvote than post a refutation /s