News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by usrbinbash on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:35AM (#38579581)
> The documents are written on simple copy paper and lack any kind of security features.

Wait, sorry, sorry, sorry, hold up, full stop...could you repeat that again?

These orders arrive AS GODDAMN PAPER PRINTOUTS?!?

Am I to understand that official orders that instruct telco providers to provide the private communication data of people, are transmitted as smushes of pigment on thin pieces of wood-paste, instead of a digitally signed file that the recipient can trivially verify with the ordering entities public key?

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by eqvinox on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:53AM (#38579685)
> Am I to understand that official orders that instruct telco providers to provide the private communication data of people, are transmitted as smushes of pigment on thin pieces of wood-paste,

Yes. Or a PDF attachment on an e-mail, possibly scanned from something that was printed a few minutes earlier because someone had to sign it with a pen.

> trivially verify with the ordering entities public key

You're underestimating the complexity of establishing a PKI infrastructure to handle federal, state and local authorities, signalling which keys have what exact authority, revoking compromised keys, … and then doing tech support for some redneck judge that owns more guns than electronic devices.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by hnfong on Saturday December 09, 2023 @03:11AM (#38579781)
Having a cert from a validated *.gov CA doesn’t seem that complicated, or at least, should be “just as complicated” as setting up properly TLs certs.

Getting the tech adopted might be difficult (like you say some judges may not see the point of it) but the PKI doesn’t have to be super complicated…

Having different authorities provide signatures for different types of documents may or may not be needed, in theory it is more secure, but just checking the domain name suffix should be a good start. And every tech literate person has a general idea how to tell “valid” domain names from phishing sites, so the scheme translates well

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by ben_w on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:14AM (#38580109)
> Having a cert from a validated *.gov CA doesn’t seem that complicated, or at least, should be “just as complicated” as setting up properly TLs certs.

You're not wrong, but you are overestimating the tech skill level of the average non techie.

I'm travelling right now, and a surprising fraction of restaurant websites here aren't https.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by hnfong on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:00AM (#38581961)
Yes, but we're talking about the judiciary here, not restaurants... Surely they'd have a minimal IT department...
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by ben_w on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:20AM (#38582108)
You might hope so, but I have no reason to think they are magically more ept than anyone else.

I don't know much about the American ones, but the British ones are complaining about the ceilings falling down due to chronic underfunding of basic maintenance; getting the digital infrastructure right is probably lower down their wish list than ceilings that don't collapse:

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/courtroom-shut-ceilin...

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by kotaKat on Saturday December 09, 2023 @01:01PM (#38584051)
I pointed this out in a previous post elsewhere but there are places out there with little to no manpower, period.

https://www.wwnytv.com/2023/11/15/st-lawrence-county-struggl...

A single judge, and likely, a single court clerk, are the only people in many, many rural courthouses. And sometimes, that judge themselves might have been able to get into the job with one vote as a joke. Neither of them could have any IT support, just a couple laptops from the county if that to help them out.

These courts out there run a lot more on paper and fax and occasionally normal email (https is 'secure email' right? /s). They'd have zero clue what a CA even is, other than the Golden State.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by pixl97 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @01:56PM (#38584634)
>Surely they'd have a minimal IT department...

That is horrifically underfunded, so the pay is low, so the employees get poached all the time. I have a bit more insider information here than most as I had family that has worked in the court system and law enforcement 20+ years, and was good friends with IT at the county.

These counties are generally so busy fixing past problems there is zero time, budget, and manpower to implement new technology like you're talking about. Seriously recovering encrypted systems is a major part of their time. As to the poaching, the number one 'company' that poached good IT people in the county was the feds. They tend to pay a lot more, and they too are generally critically understaffed.

Most IT people simply don't want to work for county/state/fed at the end of the day because pay isn't great, and for that not great pay there are a lot of restrictions.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by alwaysrunning on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:07AM (#38582011)
But you also assume they wouldn't give up using it due to frustration.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by mulmen on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:27AM (#38581397)
> and then doing tech support for some redneck judge that owns more guns than electronic devices.

This is an unnecessary dig. Not all "rednecks" are dumb. They got us to the moon. Not all people who resist tech "innovation" in their space are "rednecks" or "dumb". They probably know a whole hell of a lot more about their domain than you do.

Be cautious of the toxic sense of superiority tech people have that they somehow know better than the unwashed masses, even before immersing themselves in the domain to understand and then solve problems.

Take delivery apps that have somehow made the previously thriving small business of delivering food a giant industry that loses money for everyone involved.

Adding a tech doesn't automatically make things better. When people resist your shiny new (and likely ill conceived) tech that doesn't mean they are dumb. They might just recall the sting from last time.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by bdzr on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:15AM (#38582072)
> Take delivery apps that have somehow made the previously thriving small business of delivering food a giant industry that loses money for everyone involved.

I agree with everything you said but this. It seems like an industry with sustainability problems where the consumers are winning big. It also seems like it ignores the small businesses that could never support delivery drivers in the first place. I'm not super familiar with this industry but I hear similar arguments against ride sharing which is at worst 10x better on the consumer side than it was before.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by Moru on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:59AM (#38582423)
The problem with the big tech trying to fix problem in one country can turn out destroying something that actually works better in some other country. Here in Sweden we have had something called e-invoices for a very long time. You just ordered something and the invoice ended up automatically on your bank. Just a few clicks to pay all your invoices no matter how many.

Now there are several different payment apps that wants to fight for the customers and they all require you to get their app. Or you will have to jump through five hoops to get to pay the invoice. It's called rentseeking I believe...

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by eqvinox on Saturday December 09, 2023 @11:34AM (#38583259)
> Not all "rednecks" are dumb.

I didn't call anyone dumb. Why did you jump to that?

If I translate "redneck" to my native language, the result is roughly "someone who lives away from civilization", "lacking higher education", "anti-progressive and behind the times". Those are exactly what I was aiming for, as that's the kind of person that will (by definition, essentially) have the most & worst IT support issues.

(Also—what's your definition of "redneck" when you say "rednecks got us to the moon"? By my understanding, at the point you start working on the space program you're not a "redneck" anymore…)

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by mulmen on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:19AM (#38610197)
You clearly meant redneck in a derogatory way. Your response clarifies that. It's not really necessary to use prejudice to make your point. This is an opportunity to examine your own bias.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by vintermann on Saturday December 09, 2023 @03:58AM (#38580032)
> instead of a digitally signed file that the recipient can trivially verify with the ordering entities public key?

They wouldn't want that, because they don't want it to be easy to prove that they demanded surrender either.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by ben_w on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:18AM (#38581336)
Why not?
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by ethanbond on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:03AM (#38581985)
Yeah this sounds like fringe government boogeyman stuff.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by Schiendelman on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:42AM (#38579626)
Yes, and until we pass real consequences for data breaches - protections for individuals - none of this will change.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by bdavbdav on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:47AM (#38580300)
I think their point is that the fault here is on the system that requires people comply with non verifiable warrants, as opposed to the people handing over the data.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by autoexec on Saturday December 09, 2023 @03:12AM (#38579785)
At one place I worked for we used to get them via fax! That said, you could call and verify that the person the document claimed to send it actually did.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by esaym on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:46AM (#38579649)
What, gmail is better?
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:57AM (#38579703)
> Am I to understand that official orders that instruct telco providers to provide the private communication data of people, are transmitted as smushes of pigment on thin pieces of wood-paste, instead of a digitally signed file that the recipient can trivially verify with the ordering entities public key?

Was honestly having a difficult time determining (a) if this was sarcasm or (b) you just have no idea of the technical competence of many of these jurisdictions, not to mention the complexity of managing this type of public key verification system for the number of jurisdictions involved.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by wruza on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:58AM (#38580375)
It’s amusing how much HN expects from “the outer world”.

Companies can adopt new tech in 1-2 years. Industries have around 5-10 years inertia. Bureaucracies like courts still live in the past millenia. You should be happy that they are using email.

The best security measure they will implement after this article going wide is something like “only emails from @<domain> are valid, but we’ll destroy you anyway in case a judge mistakenly sends you an order from his own gmail”.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by mulmen on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:22AM (#38581370)
> Bureaucracies like courts still live in the past millenia. You should be happy that they are using email.

This is a feature. We don't want courts to "move fast" because the consequence of breaking is far more severe than losing a few files on Google Drive.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by fallingknife on Saturday December 09, 2023 @08:42AM (#38581849)
If you don't move fast with new tech, you are broken. E.g. the article in this post.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by respondo2134 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:11AM (#38582037)
The implied assumption here is that everything needs to adopt new tech. Lots of things are essentially "as perfect as we're going to get them" and everything new is a very marginal improvement or a big step backwards.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by mulmen on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:23AM (#38582607)
The only thing broken is Verizon’s lawyer’s phone.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by wayfinder on Saturday December 09, 2023 @06:04AM (#38580811)
I mean digital signatures have really only been a thing for like 20 years, and barely because people only started caring about it more in the past 10.

While the US has been around for nearly 250 years.

And truthfully, despite a highly technical crowd, how many of y’all have actually ever sent or received a digitally signed email? If you’ve tried, you know why no one ever does it.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by csunbird on Saturday December 09, 2023 @06:50AM (#38581131)
Oh wow! In my country, legal documents like this arrive with a QR code or confirmation code attached that can be used to verify legitimacy of the document on the official e-government internet site.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by deaddodo on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:03AM (#38581983)
Every valid warrant has a verification authority contact. You are allowed to withhold access until verification can be made, and generally it can be done in 5-30mins.

I worked in a data center once, and we would have FBI contacts that would come in regularly to access criminal data (CP, terrorist communique, heavy piracy, etc). We would verify the warrant before secure entry+accompany them to the specific requested entity. I know procedures are similar + even more stringent for the medical field. Things get even more complex for small local authorities, but the idea that "just having a slip of paper" is enough is ridiculous; unless the person accepting the request is dumb/lazy/uninformed/undertrained/etc, as in any social engineering feat (in your case, the responsible person decides to not bother with the QR because their phone connection is bad, it takes too long, etc; for example).

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by PrimeMcFly on Saturday December 09, 2023 @01:34PM (#38584367)
> You are allowed to withhold access until verification can be made, and generally it can be done in 5-30mins.

So it's not like on TV where if they have the paper they can just show it to you and barge past you by force?

For arrest warrants that makes sense, but they portray search warrants the same way.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by pixl97 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:07PM (#38584785)
Search warrants can be more aggressive if they believe the searched are going to be oppositional and attempt to destroy evidence. Now for a typical business where law enforcement is going after someone else's data it's more laid back as the most law enforcement expects is the company to get on the phone with a lawyer to see if they should comply type thing.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by PrimeMcFly on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:18PM (#38584924)
That makes sense, thanks.
Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by deaddodo on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:05AM (#38601250)
> So it's not like on TV where if they have the paper they can just show it to you and barge past you by force?

Even in these cases, they still have to give you the warrant and you're able to take it up with the issuing authority/take to court the executing officers.

But yes, arrest warrants and personal search warrants can be executed expediously for evidentiary / flight concerns. It's the exception, not the rule.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by multjoy on Saturday December 09, 2023 @06:59AM (#38581188)
The much-derided SnOOPEr'S CHarteR in the UK (which actually formalised and regulated stuff that was already being done) means that while it's not a judge signing off warrants for comms data, it involves police gatekeepers (and believe me, getting a warrant to blow someone's door off is a piece of piss compared to writing up a comms data application), who then send it to an independent decision making body who then return it to the police who then upload the request to CSP systems using a pre-agreed portal with appropriate authentication.

This touchstone of 'judicial oversight' is frequently nonsense. You can't tell me that every judge who has to give a warrant for a DUI blood draw at 3am in smalltown US is giving the matter any kind of scrutiny, nor that that judge has any legal or judicial experience at all.

Re:Verizon fell for fake "search warrant," gave victim's pho... by yladiz on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:13AM (#38582052)
The point of sending a letter, compared to an email, isn’t only about proving who issued the subpoena, but also being able to prove it was received. You can’t really prove an email was received, but you can send a verified letter proving it was delivered.