News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by virgilp on Saturday December 09, 2023 @01:52AM (#38579338)
I taught a course "in a previous life" and while I wasn't anything close to as strict as you say here, I can tell you the flip side: students would copy, modify superficially (some, less superficially) and then claim "it's my work, we just talked, that's why the similarities!" (with some even having the nerve to say, "it's not copied, look, plagiarism detection software says similarity is less than x%!) Perhaps I was wrong but I really wanted the students who took the course to put in the work themselves. Just choose a different course/course set, you _knew_ this one was going to be hard!

So yeah, the guideline was that we'll be eventual judges of what was "too similar" and if you're concerned, just don't discuss implementation details with anyone. I realize it prevents honest colaboration, and that's bad too... but sometimes it's a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" kind of situation.

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by toolslive on Saturday December 09, 2023 @03:48AM (#38579990)
What we did when correcting the homework is compare the signature of the assembly output (not manually of course). You can move functions around, rename them, change the names of variables, .... but the signature of the instructions remains the same.

We caught 2 guys, of course we didn't know who copied from whom, but we quickly found out by challenging each of them with a fizz-buzz kind of question.

Re:You are never taught how to build quality software by steveBK123 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:07AM (#38582482)
Sure, but given how we all work in the real world.. there should be courses that are explicitly "group project" based.