News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta's new AI image generator was trained on 1.1B Instagr... by mr_toad on Thursday December 07, 2023 @09:15PM (#38564593)
> But is publishing a model which can generate images of Mickey a copyright violation?

A photocopier can generate images of Mickey. Does that make a photocopier illegal?

Re:Meta's new AI image generator was trained on 1.1B Instagr... by slaymaker1907 on Friday December 08, 2023 @12:58PM (#38571988)
A photocopier is extremely different because the user is providing the copyrighted material. In the AI case, it is much more like writing a Google search for the copyrighted material. If I ask an artist to draw a cartoon of Mickey Mouse in violation of copyright, the artist is in violation of copyright if they produce said drawing and give it to me. Are we to give special rights to AI that human artists don't enjoy?
Re:Meta's new AI image generator was trained on 1.1B Instagr... by JohnFen on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:11PM (#38572147)
When I've heard people talking about using copyright to defend against AI, they've always talked about it in the sense that their works being used to train the AI is where the copyright violation takes place.

That stance is clearly not supported by copyright law.

If, however, we're talking about copyright violations applying to the distribution of works generated by AI, that's an entirely different conversation. It's still not really clear-cut, but there are ways that could be in violation of copyright law.

It isn't the case that AI is being treated differently, though. The issues would be the same if a human were doing all of this stuff.