Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by unalone on Thursday December 04, 2008 @02:41AM
(#385427)
I think you could argue that part of capitalism is guaranteeing quality service, and that cartelization in this case is an effort to treat you with more respect. That's a fascinating story.
Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by delackner on Thursday December 04, 2008 @03:04AM
(#385438)
It may be fascinating, but it is also entirely anecdotal and says nothing about the country as a whole.
In the middle of Kyoto, and in downtown Tokyo I have repeatedly seen branches of major japanese banks that have lottery ticket vending booths built into their exterior walls. Talk about "disreputable"!
Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by patio11 on Thursday December 04, 2008 @03:11AM
(#385445)
I agree. In fact, this is a point that many people forget about Japan:
Just like the US is big enough to accommodate both a sub-prime crisis and Dave Ramsey, Japan is big enough to both accommodate cosmopolitan financial centers like Tokyo and small farming towns where "a bank from Tokyo" is understood as an insult.
Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by ntoshev on Thursday December 04, 2008 @08:58AM
(#385657)
I don't think "cartelization" at all. Businesses have to honour the values of the society where they operate; if they don't their customers get hostile against them. Big corporations in general are not flexible enough to fit well in every local community, so there is some tension around them.
From this point of view the story is about local community enforcing their values effectively, not cartelization.
Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by Herring on Thursday December 04, 2008 @03:04AM
(#385439)
What other understandings do they have? Gamblers can also walk 3 blocks, this attitude might end up doing more harm than good. I've heard a few things about Japan.
Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by jimbokun on Thursday December 04, 2008 @11:08AM
(#385783)
It's surprising how something as seemingly trivial as having to walk 3 blocks can change human behavior.
Re:Dave Ramsey: "Why We Don't Take Credit Cards"
by nick5768 on Thursday December 04, 2008 @01:26PM
(#385933)
This is so true.
Next door is a gambling establishment, with an ATM outside of it. I tried getting cash and the ATM refused my card.
So I ended up walking three blocks (small town, luckily) and found myself a bank branch, which took my card. I returned to the hospital, paid the bill, and went on with my day.
Some time later I mentioned to my bank manager "By the way, I think my card is bugged -- it got rejected by a reader the other day." And I told him the circumstances.
"Sir, do you remember when we gave you your credit card that you promised not to gamble with it?"
"Yes, of course. I don't gamble, ever."
"We appreciate that, sir. Neither does the bank. Nor will we permit our customers to hurt themselves by gambling. Accordingly, we do not site any of our ATMs by gambling establishments."
"Oh, I can respect that. Of course, your competitors do, and that makes them money."
"Our real competitors do not. We have an understanding with them on this issue: no honorable bank in $SMALL_TOWN_JAPAN will countenance our customers losing their livelihoods while our eyes are still white. [Japanese idiom, means "while we still draw breath"]"
"But there really is an ATM in front of it?"
"It is from a Tokyo bank, and a disreputable Tokyo bank at that. And let them put an ATM there. They have no branch in this town, nor will they ever."
"But they don't need a branch, do they?"
"No. Bank A, Bank B, Bank C, and ourselves have enough branches to have 98% share of deposit accounts in this town. A, B, and C share our understanding of the importance of protecting this community."
"Wait, so NOBODY can use that ATM?"
"Maybe they can soak some tourists. wry smile Its a free market, you know."
I've got to say, the capitalist in me thinks "Oh crikey, cartelization". The rest of me really, really likes my bank.
[Edit: I just looked in my dictionary and it says that the actual idiom is "While my eyes are still black". I guess that means my memory is faulty. Wouldn't be the first time. Take note, students of the language.]