Re:New theory claims to unite Einstein's gravity with quantu...
by a_cardboard_box on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @11:42AM
(#38533248)
If this hypothesis is true, would it give us a way to distinguish many-worlds vs. wave function collapse? If the many "worlds" are all interacting with a single classical spacetime, we should be able to measure the gravity of other worlds, right? I'm not a physicist, but that sounds a lot like dark matter to me.
Re:New theory claims to unite Einstein's gravity with quantu...
by layer8 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:40PM
(#38537308)
There is no implication that the classical spacetime wouldn’t still split into branches, possibly with different variations in the stochastic effect from each other.
Re:New theory claims to unite Einstein's gravity with quantu...
by a_cardboard_box on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:56PM
(#38539605)
Answering my own question based on Oppenheim's lecture[1]: In his theory, the stochastic interaction between quantum and classical states necessarily causes the wave function to collapse, so it is not compatible with many-worlds. Being able to measure the gravity of other quantum worlds is something predicted by semiclassical gravity, which Oppenheim calls "complete nonsense".
Re:New theory claims to unite Einstein's gravity with quantu...
by Workaccount2 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:06AM
(#38531757)
So if I am understanding this correctly:
Quantum particles can effect change (curve) spacetime without direct quantum action if you sprinkle a bit of randomness into the (quantum acting on spacetime) effect?
You can keep the classical half (the shape of spacetime) classical, if the effect of the quantum part is partially stochastic. There's a minimum amount of random noise you need for it to be mathematically consistent. So, you set up an experiment where a particle is acting on another via gravity. There's a quantity of noise you should expect to see in the gravitational force.
"Inertial Mass=Gravitational Mass" now only holds on average. The gravitational mass will effectively have a Brownian noise term added in.