This system of app review and locked-down pay-wall systems makes commercial sense for now, but ultimately it is not scalable, doesn't provide quality and is too slow. Any system that goes against the grain of a major trend, progressing along a rapid trajectory, with rapid innovation... simply will not continue.
The point at which people realize that Google and Apple are hindering innovation, will be the point at which they will open-up, and hopefully become a free platform.
(although I'm hoping before that time, our Internet infrastructure and bandwidth will be ubiquitous enough that all phones will simply boot into a browser - it's inevitable at some near point in the future).
You can have now your site accessible from the iPhone without the approval from Apple. It's not about availability, it's about the convenience of selling on the regulated highly accessible market. To sell in their store you enter the contract between them and you, the same way you'd do this if you'd want to have Walmart selling your goods instead of selling them on your own on the street, and even for selling on the street you'd have to follow the local laws.
As an app store user I disagree. User ratings in the app store are not really a useful guideline in my experience - and it often takes trying several (reasonably well rated) apps to find one that is actually usable.
For example; it took me the best part of 10 tries to find a working tourist map of a city I was visiting a few weeks ago.
The app store review process is currently broken; as you say this decision is prudish, and other review decisions are idiotic.
But I think it is generally broken too in letting too much cruft go live.
In fact, I'd happily pay a premium for a "curated" store where reviewers judged the utility of apps more strictly.
I can let my children get on the app store without worrying too much it will lead to questions I don't feel like answering at that age. I have greater confidence that getting a game for the kids won't come with overly onerous spyware. I also have a better feeling that it will generally work.
This is not the way I want to operate, but I see how it appeals to some people.
Apple is trying to move from being the cool kids counter-culture creative types alternative to the PC to being the corporate acceptable alternative to the Blackberry.
A story about karmasutra apps or ifart in the WSJ could cause a CEO to change their mind about allowing users to use their iPhone on the corp network.
And of course the best way of preventing such a story is, as we all know, to make a big splash about banning such an app
Overall I think Apple's process works, but the inconsistency is just ridiculous. Especially when your releases are time critical.
Only this has nothing to do with it.
iOS made inroads into the enterprise DESPITE the plethora of fart apps, Kama Sutra apps and such stuff.
Apple could care less about the hypothetical CEO you mention --not that 99.9% of CEOs would care about the presence of Kama Sutra apps in the app store when considering allowing the iPhone or not.
Mostly things like: employes and managers like to use it, it delivers a business advantage, we can deliver apps for our corporation in that platform.
The old fringe player Apple could - the new $trillion corporate Apple might "think different".
Remember once upon a time Microsoft was a cool fashionable young persons software company fighting against the established corporate monopolies
I'm sure this was just a new employee who was probably still in high-school when the Appstore launched and thinks anything not on the front page of reddit is ancient. But it does show a certain attitude inside Apple. Iconoclast thinking different and "we can do no wrong" is great when it's Jobs deciding you only need one mouse button - it's different when it becomes an unwillingness to even talk to your customers and users.
I seriously doubt it. Especially since they became the "$trillion corporate Apple" by not caring about those things --so why change a winning strategy?
Curating content is almost impossible to do; app stores should limit their reviews to exclude:
- viruses
- blatant spam and copyright violations
and THAT'S IT. Assessing the quality of an app is what users' ratings are for (and of course excluding adult content is just childish).